"Limited upside" -That's a positive? Other than that sounds similar, but not quite as good as Kyle.
Per Pro Football Weekly : Kyle Williams 9th Best DT (McCargo was 3rd best)
Upside: Quick off the ball. Explosive & naturally STRONG. Very determined competitor who imposes his will. Plays to the whistle. Very TOUGH. Extremely strong in upper & lower body. Excellent motor. Plays above his ability. Hustles & chases & makes a lot of tackles in pursuit through sheer effort & determination. Is quick to find the ball. Vocal leader. Plays through pain. Outstanding work habits. Married.
Downside: Lacks ideal size. Has short arms & could have a more difficult time disengaging from NFL blockers. Not a great athlete. Too straight-linish & does not look natural changing direction. Overly muscular & ridgid in his movement. Will rise out of his stance & play too tall. Can be late to locate & react to the ball when he is tied up. Plays out of control. Not a creative pass rusher. Gives up too much of his chest & does not show many moves to come free. Hand use could improve.
The Way We See It: Does not have great measurables but plays much bigger than his size & warrants comparisons to Vickings 2000 1st rnd pick & current Buccaneers DT Chris Hovan. A rolling ball of butcher knives, (I love that line) he will slap & push around anything in his way to get in the backfield. A throwback, old school tough guy who needs to play in a penetrating, upfield attack where he is on the move.
2006 Draft projection 3rd rnd.