I wanted JP to be given a fair shot. It is obvious now that JP will be gone at the end of the season, so I want Trent to start & play well. I wish I had your confidence in Edwards, but after watching him last year, play poorly in the 4th quarter in many games, & play poorly in bad weather, I don't see what you see in him. I do hope you are right about him. I think if HEALTHY Simms is definitely worth a third, but I don't know that he is or will ever be healthy again, anymore than you or I know what kind of QB Trent will become.