Ok, when I watch the news I'll totally discount anything they say because I haven't seen it? Draft gurus are news researchers about all the players. It's a full time job. So I take what they say and view it from a researched stance. You don't think they sit around never watching tape, never doing interviews and makin crap up do you? I don't see what's wrong with respecting their research. Do you only believe what you see?
As far as rookie seasons go I normally don't rate guys either but 3 tackles and zero sacks in a rookie season when the DE position was thin says a lot to me. JMO