When's the last time Duke won a national championship? I'm not even sure what that arguement is supposed to mean. If the Bills win the Superbowl should we shutup about it next year?
Duke, UConn, Kentucky......never play cupcake non-conference games. That arguement holds no water.
I'll agree that SU is an underacheiver when it comes to the tourney, I don't think it can be argued. But 4 final fours and 3 national championship games is pretty good for an underacheiver. Especially when it doesn't have the draw that a Duke or Kentucky has to young kids.