Football is a team game. At his peak in an individual game, no NFL player comes close to Allen's ability to take over a game by himself. Peak game Josh is the best player in NFL history. Herbert does not compare at this measure. He does not compare to Allen in any other way either. This does not mean Herbert is not a good QB. The league has actually entered a golden age of very productive QBs. Herbert is a very productive QB who had a very bad game yesterday.