If you’re looking at yards per touch, sure.
McCaffrey is averaging 8.5 yards per catch to Singletary’s 6.7 in that same time period.
your numbers are wrong btw. Singletary is 4.9 yards per touch to McCaffrey’s 5.4 in the last three seasons.
If I had to rank it in my own head, an addition of someone like OBJ is infinitely more valuable and I would bang on the table much harder for him if it was possible.
If it’s “add noone or add CMC,” then I lean to add CMC
He lacks the burst and speed to make routine plays that many other players in the NFL can make. He cannot beat other players to the edge, which limits him as a player.
The water is warm my friend.
He left a ton of plays on the field. Including scoring plays that we watch being made ALL OVER the NFL every week.
He’s decent. Nice kid. But his inability to burst is a PROBLEM
Singletary is INCAPABLE of beating defenders to the edge. He should have scored before the McKenzie spasm on 4th down. TJ Yeldon would have scored there. Wide open hole.
They DEFINITELY do not believe in him. They drafted him, but they brought in slobs like Yeldon and Frank Gore. They drafted Moss and then Cook both high.
He will not be retained this year.
He’s a JAG