He’s actually been given too much credit by some and hasn’t been held accountable for a lot also. He was often to slow to react or didn’t have answers for pressure, he took way too long to develop a running game and even then didn’t understand it’s limitations, never developed a proper screen game, relied o Josh’s legs to bail out poor execution or poor play design or play calling. Not always the best at utilizing the strengths of his assets, and often got away from what was working.
He absolutely has had great success here, but even in his last game all his flaws were exposed. Has a good scripted opening drive, then went conservative until they finally had to unleash Allen. Having a series with 3 runs and a punt was ridiculous, running on 3rd and 4 without knowing you will go for it on 4th down inexcusable. Yes wonderful if you succeed there, but you didn’t, he chose Singletary over Allen to make a difference when that has never been sustainable.
Any competent OC. can succeed with Allen, but we need more than that so we don’t piss Josh’s best years away….