Why is it that we always have to be portrayed as so polarized, i.e. "worshippers" or "haters" or whatever? I'm with you as far not knowing what he will ultimately become, because it is obviously far, far too early to do so.
I think that except for the lunatic fringe on either side of the issue, most of us are neither ready to dump him, nor to anoint him to Canton, particularly after one scrimmage.
I just think he did pretty well his first time out, and am really amazed that some would already be throwing him under the bus.