JaCrispy

Well, the OP actually requires 2 answers imo... 1. Yes- Josh is a franchise QB in the sense that the FO has chosen him to be the guy to lead the franchise...Josh is the guy that hopes are pinned on, and the guy that dictates whether jobs are on the line... 2. No- Josh is not the franchise (yet) because he hasn’t reached the talent level where he is the unquestioned starter 10 years from now...if he stopped improving today, one would not feel comfortable that he is capable of bringing success to the franchise... So, this is why I feel there are two sides to the “franchise QB” question. PS I flat out disagree with the idea of “cutting bait” with Josh...that’s a little over the top at this juncture...that debate can be had the day Josh stops improving- which may be a day where he has improved to the point where letting him go would be unthinkable.

Mostly inaccurate throws, but I noticed that he wasn’t stepping into those throws- and was short arming most of them...when he side arms the throws you notice they tend to sail high... Clean up the mechanics and more consistency will follow imo...

Can’t do it...one of the most embarrassing Bills losses ever!

Was thinking the same...the all blacks look pretty sweet...

Mims is the guy I want but I have a feel he will be taken bottom of the 1st, unfortunately...

No doubt one of the best throws I’ve ever seen...along with the throw to Beasley when Allen was under pressure in the end zone against the Cowboys...?

Scott!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Winner winner chicken dinner! ?

Hmmm...You raise a good point...no shorts would definitely make it more interesting....but still, I would have to wait til live action (shorts or no shorts) to make a final judgment. ?

Love it! Sign me up...would be a great 1-2 punch!

I was specifically referring to the deep ball, since that was what the video was of... Second, I’m not miserable in the least...I’m just not giddy over two guys in shorts playing catch, as some others appear to be... Nothing wrong with that....

May not be what you wanted to hear but it doesn’t make it untrue...

Then I’m happy for you...but I’ve seen Josh already do this many times in the training camp videos, and it meant nothing in the regular season... But who cares what I think...get excited all you want! ?

Look, I’m cautiously optimistic Josh can get better, but if you think a guy in shorts playing catch in the backyard is enough to get me excited, you’ve got another thing coming... Just like Han Solo says “Good against remotes is one thing, good against the living is something else.” ? But if you want to get excited, all the power to ya! Only thing that will get me excited is seeing it in live action...

Not trying to be an ass...it’s an honest question...I read the title and then the OP and couldn’t see where they had anything to do with each other...??‍♂️

I don’t view that definition as a “bust”...to me a “bust” is when a player drafted fairly high doesn’t even manage to become a serviceable player- likely resulting in being cut, or out of the league in short order (ie Jamarcus Russel, EJ Manuel, Jonny Manzeil, JP Losman)....Sammy is not a bust imho, but rather a mediocre player...

Meh, QBs in their shorts can do this all day in there sleep when there is no defense...

Still wondering what any of this has to do with Diggs...??‍♂️

I like it...he is a vet and a proven winner...could probably help Josh more than Barkley....

Nothing wrong with trying to stay hopeful...obviously, if things change when the time comes, then society will adjust accordingly...

they will probably try to draft a guy ranked between 30-45 on their board...

Makes sense...McD only wants to build an offense that scores 21 points a game...

Hey! Josh has his issues, but he’s not that bad! Tisk tisk...?

What worried me most about Allen is that when the pressure grew in that Texans games, the worse he got...he’s gotta prove he can handle stressful situations and not flake out like he did...it was embarrassing to watch...and is not how a franchise QB responds...

I have noticed as well...very illuminating- almost like Josh is a blood relative...