I mean sure, it’s always going to be subjective. The issue I have is adding guys like Baugh, Luckman, and Otto Graham ahead of him. Different era. Much different competition.Different leagues.
I also don’t think Aikman was a better QB but our system of ranking players in a team sport based on championships has skewed the vote in most cases.
If you gave 100 different people an opportunity to make this list. There would be 100 different submissions.