I would in a heart beat. Manning is learning a new offense. Has thrown for over 4,000 numerous times in his career and it a 2 time Superbowl champ. Is funny that people are mocking this topic, but if the poster asked if they would trade EJ for Brady straight up then most people would do that in a heat beat.
As much as I currently support E.J Manual I would not pass up a chance to get Eli. He just passed Jim Kelly for career touchdowns thrown and Eli is only 33 years old and also in his 11th year which is the same amount of time Jim Kelly played for the Bills. Plus he is durable with him owning the 3rd longest consecutive starts by a QB currently at 154 and counting.
And yes if it took Cj Spiller who is in the last year of his contract who I love as player and person to pull it off then so be it.
Will all this being said that the chance of this trade happening is less than me hitting the lottery.
At this point I would trade EJ Manuel for Ryan Nassib straight up!