I think there are some posters who are really smart about talent evaluation and know how to watch film and I trust their opinions but those that get paid by nfl teams to do it as a profession ofc I will lean that way if there is disagreement. That said no one is perfect and nfl teams make scouting errors and drafting errors as it is not an exact science and yeah there is a lot of luck involved too. I think the biggest thing is that teams have so much info on players, that the public just doesn’t have access to. Sometimes that info can shape boards and decisions.