This thread is a parody mocking intellectual dishonesty.
Go to the root of the issue.
Gary created a poll thread forwarding a logical fallacy as a talking point designed to be derogatory in nature. He decided, when called out for this, to delete the thread because he didn't want his intellectual dishonesty discussed, to delete the thread and to recreate it disabling comments.
His poor behavior created the situation. Don't paper over that because you generally agree with his view point. It does a great deal of intellectual harm to your position, and makes further conversation impossible.