FireChan

Tanny had played his second season when EJ played his first. There's no way you could compare just their first seasons, because they happened at different times.

We'll never know that. I know I would've traded Manuel for Tanny looking at Manuel's first and Tanny's second season.

You answered the question with your second sentence. Your tired defense of "rah rah Kyle Orton, rah rah 1 win against Tanny because he's only been good/healthy to play him once" means nothing in this topic.

Stopped reading right there. Thank you.

I think the answer you're looking for is, "no."

If you don't pay him, someone else will. Hence the one year rental.

You'd trade EJ for a one year rental? Tanny is gonna get paid a massive amount of money by somebody.

A repeat of last year's, with a poll! http://forums.twobillsdrive.com/topic/170205-would-you-right-now-trade-ej-for-tannehill-straight-up/ For me, it's a yes. Try not to turn this into a full EJ topic. I want to get a baseline on the career's of two young QB's in the AFC East, not talk Matt Cassel.

Ah, the new NFL, where your best chance to win a Super Bowl is during your QB's rookie deal. Exactly. I can see how someone could draw that conclusion if they only watched him play the Bills. But he's had good and even fantastic games against teams that aren't us. I think he has the best record vs NE in our division.

Tannehill has won more than 8 games as a starter. Tannehill has outdueled Brady. To say that EJ has as good of a chance means that you don't watch enough Tannehill. Tanny has already succeeded. Also, middling QB last year? Are you kidding?

I assume the theory says that the sound people had their artifacts and ruins coopted by civilizations. One day, Ramses said, "yeah, that's my tomb now."

I find it hard to believe that a civilization capable of harnessing sound waves was destroyed so utterly. Is there a time-line on this theory? Did a civilization that harnessed sound waves really utilize that kind of break through to put together stone pyramids? I'm just thinking out loud here. Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I think that technology must evolve along the same basic guidelines. Not exact in form, but close enough. Any organism that develops, in our world or across the galaxy, will use a long, thin, or sharp object as a tool. To do things their body cannot. If there's a limit to what evolution can create in terms of the "perfect organism" (meaning that a super organism who can operate a vehicle with his mind, or make a noise that drives an engine is not feasible in an evolutionary sense) means that there's a limit to what can be developed as technology. I suppose I may not be open to wilder ideas, but the thought that other organisms may just skip or not use things like fire, projectiles, water currents and other first "technologies," seems farfetched.

You were a little ambiguous before, it sounded like you said the depth chart went: Gronk - Wright - Chandler I reaaaally think you're understating the power of Bill Belichick though. If he thinks getting Chandler on the field will help them win football games, he'll get him on the field. Even in a rotational role. Hell, Wright was strictly used in goalline formations for the first 6 weeks he was a Pat, he didn't have a catch that wasn't also a TD. I don't think they'll go back to twin TE sets because they now have Chandler, but I wouldn't be surprised to see him used as a welcomed cog in their offense. Maybe they'll just use him for FG block team to keep Gronk healthy. How many did Fred lead us to? Cut him. What about Sammy? See ya!

http://forums.twobillsdrive.com/topic/176958-spiller-to-the-saints

Wright is no more talented than Chandler, IMO. It's not like he had a storied career in Tampa.

If I thought the Dolphins would stand between us and the playoffs, this would be better.

What did they rank in YPG?

I don't think the plan is to start guys based on upside.

Did you know that sometimes great defenses have poor outings?

Fit him for his jacket!

Clearly, you forgot those legendary 500 yard seasons for Pierre Thomas.

Fool me three times...

I'm excited to have some more possible starters on the roster.

Big man making fun of Matt Cassel. Are you in the top 1% of your profession? How jealous of his income are you?

Lots of big men in here making fun of guys who already won at life.