A little logic lesson: If "A" then "B" does not logically equate to If "not A" then "not B." As an example, people say that "If you masturbate you will go blind." Does that mean that if you don't masturbate you won't go blind? Your quote of John 3:16 supports what I said before: believe and you are in. It doesn't say "don't believe and you won't get in."
As I said above, the quotes support what I said.
Where is the word only in there? Not in any of the four versions I read before giving up. The phrase relates to the fact that salvation through faith is God's doing, not man's.
You're right in correcting my mis-spoken words about the New Covenant being made to all, Jew and Gentile. I still say, and the Roman Catholic Church in Vatican II concurred, that while the only way to God is through Jesus, and God's grace came to all of us through the death of Jesus, it isn't necessarily so that only Christians are saved, or, more succinctly, only people who are Christians at the time of their death are saved. Chew on the semantics there a bit before responding...it's a long sentence . Read up on Romans 2:11-16. In Matthew 25 Jesus himself says that on judgement day that people will not be sorted by faith, but by deed. Call them 'implicit believers' or 'anonymous Christians,' but there are those who have led a good life who called God by another name You may be content with the notion that Ghandi, for example, is burning in perdition, but I am not.
In the end we may agree to disagree on this, but I appreciate the chance to debate with you. If this side-chatter annoys others we can talk further through PM's, but I certainly invite the opportunity to share in fair debate. It is yet another way that us Kool-Aid drinkers can learn how to come closer to our God.