Jump to content

TheFunPolice

Community Member
  • Posts

    18,156
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TheFunPolice

  1. Rodgers still has the arm. Fun game to watch!
  2. Terrible punt. Your defense can barely slow them down.
  3. This is a fun game! I expected a Steelers collapse once the Bengals got ahead
  4. Plus once the momentum shifts there are flags on the Steelers defense every other play. It's like it's....
  5. 3-4 if they win. That's no miracle. They could win that division
  6. When games switch like this the pass interference penalties always come
  7. This game is over Everything is going the Bengals way
  8. Steelers are such pretenders. They could be 15-2 and I wouldn't take them seriously. That said, go Steelers! Bengals and Ravens still play each other twice.
  9. There are some diva WR, but the vast majority of star WR just show up and ball.
  10. Familiarity. Same reason we signed a guy with a career ending neck injury to the practice squad last year, completely wasting a roster spot. For the record, I would absolutely let McDermott go if this team doesn't get to the Super Bowl this year.
  11. One could conclude that McDermott doesn't like many of Beane's picks
  12. The more I post about this and think about it, the more I am certain: McDermott is fine. This roster is not great. Beane must go. But he won't. Look for a 1st round DB who McDermott can't stand, a 2nd round DL who McDermott won't dress for games, and a 3rd round LB who McDermott won't play because he's a rookie. But these guys are one mind, right?!
  13. McDermott is a better coach than Sirianni. And it's not even close, IMO. Yet Sirianni has been to 2 Super Bowls and won 1 with Jalen Hurts. Really he should have won both, had Hurts not had that fluke fumble. Allen is worlds better than Hurts (IMO) so what is it? It was KC both Super Bowls. Eagles roster is stacked with talent. Bills roster is stuck in the past resigning guys from 5 years ago because there is no better option. That is 100% the direct result of the GM failing to find players to replace them. Beane needs to be let go at the end of the season unless the team at least gets to the Super Bowl. He got Allen. Aside from that, any competent GM could do no worse in roster management. I bet McDermott's defenses look a lot better with an elite corner and a DE who is a problem for opposing offenses. Beane has tried and tried again and has yet to get this done. I bet McDermott's offense looks a lot better with an elite WR. This is where the GM says "here's Waddle or Olave" and the HC makes it work, because the goal is to win a Super Bowl, not get to the playoffs and be eliminated every year.
  14. All time great QBs do not equal "drought" The problem is twofold as I see it: 1. Our defensive minded HC has a scheme that no longer works (if it ever really did). It relies on smaller, faster players who are going to get hurt more often because of the nature of having a 225 pound LB getting blocked by OL who outweigh him by 100+ pounds play after play. It relies on keeping everything in front, and eventually the offense will make a mistake. It works often against mediocre QBs, but not against most of the guys you see in the playoffs. This carries over into the overall philosophy of the team: low event football as some call it. So exciting. Keep it clean, limit mistakes, make a play when you have to. Again, many teams are sloppy, undisciplined, and will often hand you the game if you play this way, so you'll rack up wins. But it doesn't work against great teams very often. 2. The GM is not very good. He is living off of drafting Allen, which was amazing for this franchise. But his free agent signings have been so-so at best, his draft picks, especially high ones, are so bad the HC who he is supposedly one mind with doesn't want to play them, and his roster build is so bad we're bringing back a guy with a broken neck who cannot or should not even play to sign to the practice squad and waste a space for no apparent reason last year, and this year we're signing back a bunch of players we let go ostensibly because they weren't good enough. This is an admission that the GM has failed time and time again to find suitable replacements for these players. There is no other way to say it, as much as we love these players as human beings and for what they did here. I'm not even kidding: Andre Reed would have had a better chance of seeing the field and making a contribution last season than Hyde. This is no shot at Hyde, the man had a career ending injury. But why was he taking up a spot on the practice squad? This GM has to go, and if the coach was fired as well I am fine with it. But Beane is by FAR the bigger issue.
  15. I also thought this, but then it seems like McDermott often is reluctant to play the guys Beane drafts, especially early rounders. Later round guys seem to do much better, which is odd. It makes me wonder if someone is more involved early and less involved late or something. It defies logic. IMO McDermott is going to get Allen's entire career, so the best we can hope for is a GM who does a better job at building the roster and has a little bit of independence from McD. I have major issues with McDermott's defensive scheme, but no doubt it would look better if Beane's DL or S picks were better.
  16. I don't think he was that bad. He's not the same guy he was, but he is FAR from the biggest issue on defense. Neither of our safeties can play. Our undersized LBers are always getting hurt. Our DE's are basically nonexistent. The real issue? The defense keeps bringing back guys it let go because the GM has FAILED to replace them. Last year we actually signed a guy who shouldn't/couldn't even play to the practice squad (Hyde). That was insanely bad roster management.
  17. Beane and McDermott have Allen's entire career here. If either one goes it's Beane and that is unlikely
  18. Well, Kenneth Davis would be on the field every 3rd down and Thurman would be watching during the final drive of the Giants SB
  19. This staff could have Barry Sanders in his prime and he'd be watching Ty Johnson trot out there in that scenario
  20. The football gods were displeased... Washington fumbled the handoff on 3rd and short on the very next play! Lol
  21. It gets worse Washington is playing Mr. Brightside with 3:10 to go...
  22. I bet opposing defenses never notice that obvious tell either!
  23. It will get loud in national media. The "they are wasting Allen" narrative was already a thing in recent years. I would fire him, but Pegula never will. So best we can hope for is finding an independent GM who is better at hitting on draft picks and signings. If our DEs could get home or our DBs could cover or WR get open then suddenly McDermott would look better.
  24. They refused to play Cook in the most important minutes in the AFC championship game too It's a pattern: crunch time= send your elite playmaker to the sidelines It's inexplicable I love Cook and don't blame him. He wants to be out there helping his team when they need him most. I honestly don't get it. If you're going down, go down with your best guys having a chance at least.
×
×
  • Create New...