Who gets your vote??
Both played 16 years, Reed finished with 13,198 yards,951 receptions, 87 touchdowns, and 7 PRO BOWLS.
Carter finished with 13,899 yards, 1,101 receptions, 130, touchdowns, and 8 PRO BOWLS
Vert comparible stats, Reed gets my vote because he has been eligible longer and I believe was more valuable to his team, a team that won 4 consecutive AFC titles.