Who would you rather have over Losman?

[truth on hold]

i think i'm going wih pennington. not a strong arm and injury prone, but very competitive and runs great misdirection and play-action plays. he's a "mudder" that could be a winner in buffalo.

[JimBob2232]

I go with Linert only because i think the likelyhood oh linert having a HOF career is the greatest out of the list

[daquixers_is_back]

I think Cutler will be darn good someday.

[Scraps]

Drew Brees.

[truth on hold]

  Scraps said:

Drew Brees.

817063[/snapback]

too easy an answer! couldn't have put him on list

[Tcali]

  jduncan1 said:

i think i'm going wih pennington.  not a strong arm and injury prone, but very competitive and runs great misdirection and play-action plays.  he's a "mudder" that could be a winner in buffalo.

817032[/snapback]

Pennington,Leinart,Cutler

[Astrobot]

It isn't about the QB.

I'll take Losman.

[ExiledInIllinois]

They could have had Leinart and got Donte Whitner...

[daquixers_is_back]

  ExiledInIllinois said:

They could have had Leinart and got Donte Whitner...  

817070[/snapback]

 

THATS what bugs me. We could have most likely picked up Leinart and still have gotten Whitner.

[truth on hold]

  daquixers_is_back said:

THATS what bugs me. We could have most likely picked up Leinart and still have gotten Whitner.

817073[/snapback]

wow, that does stink when you think about it. but i guess they really wanted mccargo and didn't want to hurt losmans feelings

[Rico]

  daquixers_is_back said:

THATS what bugs me. We could have most likely picked up Leinart and still have gotten Whitner.

817073[/snapback]

But then we wouldn't have McCargo. :lol:

[daquixers_is_back]

  Rico said:

But then we wouldn't have McCargo.  :lol:

817075[/snapback]

 

Who cares. We would have Cutler or Leinart ....

[Rico]

  daquixers_is_back said:

Who cares. We would have Cutler or Leinart ....

817077[/snapback]

Well, maybe next year McCargo will stay healthy & actually look good.

And if Tripplett still sucks, you'll be glad that McCargo is around.

 

It could be.

[daquixers_is_back]

  Rico said:

Well, maybe next year McCargo will stay healthy & actually look good.

And if Tripplett still sucks, you'll be glad that McCargo is around.

 

It could be.

817091[/snapback]

 

Id rather have a good OFFENSE than a good defense. We had a top 3 defense for TWO STRAIGHT YEARS and we couldnt make the playoffs.

[DeLuca1967]

All of the above.

[VABills]

Where are the options for Joe Fergeson, the player of the week from the areas pee-wee football team, or maybe even the high school player of the week?

[/dev/null]

Of those choices I'd say Cutler

 

Honorable mention:

Drew Brees (already discussed)

Kellen Clemmons (Jets 2nd rounder)

[Rico]

  VABills said:

Where are the options for Joe Fergeson, the player of the week from the areas pee-wee football team, or maybe even the high school player of the week?

817140[/snapback]

No Flutie either.

[VABills]

  Rico said:

No Flutie either.

817154[/snapback]

The peewee football player is bigger, so I didn't think he was a valid option.

[Orton's Arm]

I voted for Cutler. While both Leinart and Cutler may well have successful careers, Cutler's arm would give him an edge in windy Ralph Wilson Stadium.