T&C Posted April 9, 2024 Posted April 9, 2024 Once you put the word Trans in front of the word Woman you're already saying it's a man no matter what kind of genitalia mutilation someone has had had done.
The Frankish Reich Posted April 11, 2024 Author Posted April 11, 2024 JK Rowling takes the bait on that whole "define a woman" thing. In the old print days, the saying was "don't pick an argument with someone who buys ink by the gallon." The modern-day equivalent: "don't expect to win a written argument against the most successful writer of our age." Burn baby, burn!
Doc Posted April 21, 2024 Posted April 21, 2024 1 hour ago, B-Man said: Exactly. It's how they frame everything.
JDHillFan Posted May 12, 2024 Posted May 12, 2024 She’s so hateful! Also normal and common sensical. You go girl! 2
JDHillFan Posted July 21, 2024 Posted July 21, 2024 She’s incredible. Also a hateful bigoted transphobe that should be canceled or some such horsesh*t.
B-Man Posted April 19 Posted April 19 With the British Supreme Court ruling on women maybe she should be quieter. . . . . . . . . . . . yeah right.
B-Man Posted April 21 Posted April 21 Janice isn't claiming to speak for all women, @PennyRed, but given that you aren't one ('the category of "woman" does not fully describe my lived experience') it's hard to see why you should be speaking for any women at all. Literally nobody thinks the Supreme Court ruling 'legislates trans people out of existence.' Trans people have exactly the same rights and protections they had before the ruling, and unless they've mass combusted while I wasn't paying attention, I'm fairly sure they continue to exist. If some trans-identified people in the UK are currently experiencing rage and disappointment because the Supreme Court clarified that they don't have rights they believed they had, the responsibility lies firmly with activist groups and sections of the media who've persistently argued, falsely, that gender transition turned a person into the opposite sex for all practical purposes in the eyes of the law. You can personally take some responsibility for that state of affairs, of course, because you've spent the last few years enthusiastically championing the removal of single-sex spaces for women and girls.
Recommended Posts