Ive always felt Peters was overrated by the media and a lot of fans, most likely because he is a converted TE that wasnt drafted. Is he good, yes, is he as good as Walter Jones, Pace or Ogden were in their prime, absolutely not. Could he be, maybe but he isnt anywhere near there yet. I still think he looks raw at times and as someone else mentioned, he is a better pass blocker then run blocker.
I would take Joe Thomas over him in a heartbeat.