CMC has more potential. His injury history negates that.
I think if given the ball consistently, DS could be a very good back. Showed flashes last weekend and then was pulled for Moss and then Cook. If DS had the hole Cook did on his TD, he’d have scored also. When given the ball again, he made a nice couple of runs.
I didn’t see any obviously mistakes for him being pulled, but it seems apparent this coaching staff is no settled on DS being RB1.
That being said, I have no interest in CMC because of his injury history and the disruption on the team. No way we keep him past this year anyway with a cap hit like he has. I’m sure he’d restructure, just don’t see him ever being cap friendly.