UKBillFan

Agree to an extent. But there will be a point where Josh will have to choose between loyalty and a Super Bowl ring if this approach continues.

For all the finger pointing at Beane, he doesn't draft in a silo. McDermott surely has a big say on who he wants too, particularly on defense and where he wants to focus picks when it comes to the roster? Plus wasn't Josh the one who asked for Coleman?

In the last two weeks we would have needed 24 and 25 to win.

Just because the offense was a mess tonight doesn't mean the defense isn't a serious issue. I trust, maybe with a new OC and one key trade (who then doesn't pick up an injury), the offense will sort it out. I think the issue with the defense goes far deeper. It's still a fact the D let the Falcons play down the field and get into scoring range. Which it seems to do all too often. I said during the game the issue with the D is it's too reliant on turnovers. Without them, it has little of note or benefit. In the stupid crazy world of sport this means the Bills will go to Charlotte and win in just under a couple of weeks.

Are you saying this in hindsight?

You're right. But the Falcons would have been on 30 had they not turned down the chance of a FG in the first and, yes, thanks to a rare good ST play, had another blocked in the second. Then you're in shootout territory.

The big question is why is McDermott being ignored. He says publically "Don't be cute". And yet calls in key situations continue to be cute.

Someone else said it but the defense looked better with him (and Bishop, obviously) out.

Though this is partly the point of the draft and SoS - to even the playing field. You have to have at least an extremely smart GM or HC to keep things ticking over. The Bills seem to have neither.

And Kincaid. Plus, unless Cook was injured, there's no excuse for what happened in the 4th.

Yep. And that season finished with a victory in the Super Bo... oh wait.

And a Josh Allen problem. This isn't all on him, but he's bottoming out and exposing what a mess we have elsewhere without a QB playing at MVP level on the roster.

Starting to think, for the long term, it would have been better if we had.

In the defense's defence they were probably burned out. Offense gave them nothing.

I don't want to make a Super Bowl with this offense. It's horrific. The warning signs were there from week one but most tried to ignore them.