FireChans

The players/coaches/fans popularity contest still didn't see it. Milano wasn't even a ProBowler. All-Pro has always mattered more in player circles and HoF voting etc. Your opinion is your opinion.

Cody Ford was *this* close to getting a vote per my sources in Arizona. Josh almost led the league in picks and had a stretch of a couple games riddled with some head scratching plays. The standard being "third in All-Pro voting" in a relatively not historically insane year is pretty good.

Lmao took the national media 5 years to see that our best LBer isn't the top 16 pick, but the fifth rounder from Boston College. You're entirely wrong about which matters more lol.

Draft impact positions high too. Draft players you will pay to keep if they make a ProBowl once in their rooke contract. Which includes EDGE/CB/WR/OT only. Drafting an OG in the first is just as bad as drafting a RB unless he's the best in the league. And even then.....

Most players aren't watching AD all year. How many times has Josh Allen watched AD tape this year? Once. Before week one.

He has a great reputation. He didn't have a great year. Brady is an All-Time QB. He didn't deserve to make the list either.

Correct, which is why it's silly that he's on this list.

74th in the NFL in sacks. 85th in QB hits. 38th in TFL's. Sounds like the best DT in football this year to me lmao.

All it takes is one. "For too long, we as NFL players have allowed everyone else to define the best of us. That ends now," NFLPA president J.C. Tretter wrote in an email to players, per the NFL Network. This was a way for the NFL players to try to have their own list to compete with the AP due to "bias." And then they put AD on their and killed their own point in its crib.

Nah they did the exact same thing they always complain about. Putting AD on the list is stupid and based solely on reputation. Good to know they are no better than the AP

lol. lmao. Bills will be up 7-3 in the first Q and these folks will be screaming about how 'we took them too lightly" on our way to a 38-6 romping.

No one ranks offense by “being denied 2 drives.” However, most people don’t include ST or defensive TD’s in offensive production

I’m not sure two kick returns count as offense.

You should watch some Cardinals games. Kyler runs around more than anyone.

I drafted Parker in fantasy like 3 years in a row because he always dominated the Bills and I thought he was nasty.

Witness Kangaxx.

What straw man? He’s not signed.

Evidence of him not being signed is evidence of him not being signed. Lol

So you think you knew better than Beane IRT those picks. Because he did his own research and disagreed with you. Thanks for playing.

I’m not sure either but it’s uniquely hilarious to hear it every other year. Bama fans and Georgia fans know their dudes are backups at best for the most part. Clemson fans knew that Watson and Lawrence were special talents but DJ was a bum. Watching Bucks fans trip over themselves to explain why the next Cardale Jones could be a franchise QB in the NFL because of 3 games in college playing with future first round WR’s is one of my guilty pleasures.

It's a message board. Well, we'd have the same number of SB wins, that's for sure lol. You're a know-it-all too right? You hated the Elam pick, the Basham pick, the Doyle pick, the Bernard pick? Why did you hate them? Because you thought you knew better than Beane?

It's not top secret info that Edmunds is playing on his fifth year option and unsigned for next year. Tre White was extended in September of year 4. Josh was extended August of year 4. Tremaine was left twisting in the wind in year 5 like Stephon GIlmore (who also was not re-signed)

Every year it's, "This OSU QB is different and a much better prospect than the old OSU QB." Cardale Jones was nothing like JT Barrett who was nothing like Braxton Miller who was nothing like Dwayne Haskins who was nothing like Justin Fields who was nothing like CJ Stroud. OSU is a bust QB factory. These guys all play with NFL top tier WR talent, and struggle against tomato cans like Northwestern. At least Michigan fans know their bums like JJ McCarthy have no shot in the pros.

No? I would be ecstatic with a 1st or 2nd round WR. In this upcoming class, a third rounder would be meh. I just think the Bills philosophy is a little more "Josh can cover holes on offense, we need as many playmakers as possible on defense" than I would like. Combined with the fact that I think this years draft is a little WR top-heavy, Von may not be healthy entering next season, and Antonio Johnson may be bouncing around the late 20s, I just don't see Beane doing a reach for a WR

It's going to be like when Jamar Chase opted out of the COVID year. No one talks about that anymore lol