You draw your conclusions, I'll draw mine. I am not saying one sucks and the other doesn't. But both Johnson and Flutie did well enough to get us in the playoffs.
Collins, where has he ever started again, he is a career backup who started for us. He was Frank Reich.
Bledsoe, he did well enough, but he takes the sacks. His biggest issue was coaching and he was mis-used.
Van Pelt, nice guy but career backup/3rd stringer.