The guy is still pretty damn good. 11 Td's and 7 Int's with no talent around him. A poor oline, and his running back injured most of the year. the worst passing defense in the league, and he has a higher Qb rating then our Qb, more TD's less INT's. less fumbles, and he actually has the ability to win games for your team. Sorry I'd take Favre. He's not overrated by any stretch.