Jump to content

ngbills

Community Member
  • Posts

    5,744
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ngbills

  1. 33 minutes ago, transplantbillsfan said:

    So... let's see how our roster improves starting tonight.  I said I think the Bills will be better this upcoming season... I still think they will. 

     

    As of this moment, just hours before the draft, this is how I view the Buffalo Bills roster at the moment.

     

    And yes, we can field a 53 man team that consists of zero guys I'd strictly put in the "Practice Squad" category.

     

    LOCKS

    Close to locks

    Baseline rosterable depth 

    Players the team seems somehow invested in

     

              STARTER              2ND                                 3RD                              4TH

    QB  Josh Allen              Mitchell Trubisky      Shane Buechele

    RB  James Cook           Ty Johnson               Darrynton Evans-

    WR  Khalil Shakir          Justin Shorter          Tyrell Shavers

    WR  Curtis Samuel       Andy Isabella          Bryan Thompson

    WR  Mack Hollins         KJ Hamler

    TE   Dalton Kincaid       Dawson Knox         Quintin Morris         Tre' McKitty

    FB    Reggie Gilliam

    LT    Dion Dawkins         Ryan Van Demark   Richard Gouraige

    LG    David Edwards       Alec Anderson

    C     Connor McGovern   Will Clapp

    RG    O'Cyrus Torrence    Kevin Jarvis

    RT    Spencer Brown        La'el Collins            Tommy Doyle 

     

                STARTER              2ND                           3RD                       4TH

    LDE      Greg Rousseau    Kameron Cline

    LDT      DaQuan Jones     Austin Johnson        Eli Ankou

    RDT      Ed Oliver               DeShawn Williams

    RDE      Von Miller              AJ Epenesa              Casey Toohill       Kingsley Jonathan

    WLB      Matt Milano

    MLB      Terrel Bernard        Baylon Spector

    SLB       Nicholas Morrow    Dorian Williams

    LCB       Rasul Douglas        Kaiir Elam                   Kyron Brown

    SS         Taylor Rapp          Kendall Williamson

    FS          Mike Edwards         Cam Lewis                 Damar Hamlin

    RCB       Christian Benford    Taron Johnson         Ja'Marcus Ingram

     

                STARTER              2ND                           3RD                   4TH

    PK        Tyler Bass

    P          Sam Martin         Matt Haack

    H          Sam Martin         Matt Haack

    PR        Khalil Shakir         

    KR        Khalil Shakir         Andy Isabella

    LS        Reid Ferguson

     

    53 man roster

    34  LOCKS

    10 close to locks

    4  baseline rosterable depth 

    5  Players the team seems somehow invested in

    That is a solid 9-8 team

  2. If you got a guy like Aiyuk as a plan a or plan b - then you can sit back at 28. If you get to 28 and all the names are gone you make the trade for Aiyuk and the swap is more of a sure thing for the much higher price tag. If you dont have an Aiyuk or similar for a back up plan you do whatever it takes to move up if needed to get your guy. 

  3. I get the formation discussion but dont get the point that we dont need an X receiver. I may be taking liberties here, but most are referring more to the X as the #1 WR. The Bills do desperately need a #1 WR and that #1 is likely an X. But the NFL game has become much more dynamic than X lines up here, Y there, etc. Guys move around and your #1 will be in the slot, outside, in the backfield. Its all about creating mismatches. The Bills lack that guy (the traditional X) that teams will want to double team. WIthout it the Bills become a lot less dangerous. Nobody will be scared of Kincaid, Knox, Shakir, Samuels. 

    • Like (+1) 1
    • Thank you (+1) 1
  4. I do not expect any jail time etc. It will be a suspended license, probation, fines and community service. Kind of ridiculous if you think about it - because he got lucky no one died he does not end up like Ruggs. So the luck of the outcome is what is more important than the action. You should definitely get more severe punishment if someone dies...but if you do the exact same thing and no one dies it should not be the difference between many years in jail and nothing. That wont stop anyone from actually killing someone next time.

    • Agree 5
  5. 1 hour ago, Beck Water said:

     

    Except that's not what Josh said at all, unless by "official practices" you mean "voluntary OTAs in April" (which are, you know, voluntary and not practices)

    The comparison is that he used to go work out in LA and was basically a full go year round. Now he is taking a lot more time off. I am not saying there is anything wrong with that. The first few years he had much more to work on so had to put in the work to get better. He is much more in maintain mode now with less focus on working on things. But that is doing less.

  6. 32 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

     

    It's really embarrassing that some people think Allen doesn't work out with his WRs in the offseason because he doesn't hire a production company to show up and film it. Every single starting QB works out with their guys at some point in the offseason.

    Well some of it is based on Josh saying himself that getting rest in the offseason is what is most important to him. He takes time off until official practices start. But lets not take Josh word for it, the posters here know more about what he does. 

    • Like (+1) 1
  7. It was fun while it lasted. Bills are cash strapped and go/coach have limitations. I will gladly be wrong but let’s see how this plays out. 

    3 minutes ago, LABILLBACKER said:

    Yup, he won't be a cap problem next season also allowing us to June 1st 2025 both Von & Dawson.  We will have money available to spend on more wrs if necessary. 

    Huge cap available on 2029 season.  Woohoo. 

    • Awesome! (+1) 1
  8. This logic is basically assuming everything goes right and the old addition by subtraction holds true (which I am not a fan of because that means you have incompetent coaches making bad choices). If the Bills are not a team that on paper took a step back then I dont know what team in the league did. We lost multiple starters and all have not been replaced with a better player. That by itself would suggest a step back. It would be better to argue it is only a small step back, but to say it was a step forward? 

     

    The biggest flaws in being better are:

     

    OL - We moved our G to C and a backup G to the starting G. I dont see how that is an upgrade. The hope is this reshuffle works out. But it could be very likely that McG is worse at C than Morse and Edwards is worse at G than McG so you have two positions worse off. 

     

    Edge - Floyd being gone is not an upgrade. The hope is Von is better so we dont miss Floyd as much. But based on what we saw from Von last year that is not even close to a guarantee. 

     

    WR - Davis has not been replaced. Even if we do draft his replacement there is hope a rookie is better but its hard to say. Samuel is an upgrade over Harty. Hoskins and Sherfield are a wash. So the hope is really a rookie can step in to Davis role. 

     

    S - Hyde and Poyer played nearly every snap. Its way too easy to just say no big deal. Rapp was here last year and was not an upgrade last year. Edwards is serviceable. The hope is we dont see  a big fall off, not that we upgraded the position. 

     

    The other moves have not been as impactful. But I dont see how any position group could be viewed as an upgrade at this point. Again, its basically the flawed logic of this guy who we all used to say was good is now not good so no matter who replaces them is better. Not the end of the world. The hope is we hit on some draft picks and like we have seen with KC have some early season growing pains but see contributions from the new guys down the stretch. 

    • Agree 3
  9. I think stats can be confused with opportunity. I am not saying this is the case with Kincaid but you cant ignore how many of his catches were easy dump-offs that 99.9 % of NFL guys catch. At the end of the year we finally saw more, but for the majority of the season it was very limited.

     

    I would argue you can take any NFL talent and they would put up 800+ yard receiving season if given the chance. There are so many plays a D is just willing to give up the 5 yard pass or the D focused on better players so the 3-4 option guys are gonna be open a ton.

     

    The difference is some guys are playmakers that can make something special happen out of a 5 yard play. So every time you go to the 5 yard guy, your losing the chance that the better player does something special. So getting Joe Schmo an 800 yard season and Justin Jefferson only 1000 could be viewed as a failure not a look how great a year Joe Schmo had, that OC must be great. 

     

    Again, not saying Kincaid is in that bucket. But the O stalled quite a bit during the stretch we played the throw to Kincaid for 2 yards and watch him be tackled. I would have preferred I'm stretching the field and opening things up for Diggs. 

     

     

     

     

    • Agree 1
×
×
  • Create New...