SouthNYfan

This train is never late So you're a Brady fan?

Look I'm not saying we have the best group in the league, and there are a ton of questions (will Zay crap the bed? Was fosters second half a sign of the future or a flash in the pan? Can duke Williams ball?) But the article nails the problem with their raking. this idiot put Andre Roberts in as one of their starting wrs. He clearly did no research.

He won't be If he's who they want they need to take him

What about in the teef??

Maybe, but I think rights aren't the same as being under contract I believe they would have to negotiate a contract with him still This has turned into quite the tangent/rabbit hole

They aren't spending on free agents anymore. They are "good enough" according to cashman ?

I wonder if he pulls a Bell and takes a year off?? He's what? 5-6 years older than Bell, but he's also at the most premium position in the game, and one which guys are seemingly playing older and older at.

Not that he's always right but kiper mocked hock to us

Rw is a tough one Obviously ja is much younger and costs significantly less, but rw is pretty darn legit. I said it earlier this thread I believe, Buffalo's current roster with rw at QB is a 12 win team and an instant SB contender. Much shorter window (no pun intended) than ja because of age, but obviously he's already a proven commodity, although FA qb acquisition don't always perform as intended (and in fact they usually don't)

Wait are you talking about rw or Eli?? @BuffaloHokie13 was talking about Allen vs Eli Eli had 21td/11int and a 66% comp over 16 games Turning that into 11 games is 14td/7int over 11 games

He does

Eli had a pretty solid offense around him, including a top5 rb and wr I think a lot of his #s were empty. At the end of the day he looks done for and really worn down. I think 4k+ with 21/11 line looks amazing for Allen It doesn't look good for an immobile gun turret of a QB who provides nothing with his legs and is making $22+Milly a season against your cap.

I used to love Conan's "Walker Texas ranger lever"

I've been saying this to my Giants friends. The issue is the Cardinals are in no hurry to trade Rosen. They gave up an additional 3rd and 5th to move up from 15 to 10 to select him. I don't think they are going to toss him for scraps, which is what the Giants fans seem to think they can get him for. He's worth more to the Cardinals as insurance for Murray. Maybe they don't want to throw Murray to the wolves initially, so they'll let Rosen be puppy chow until they feel Murray is ready. They also have a reasonably priced quality backup locked down for 4 more years. I just don't see them cutting bait for anything less than a 2nd + 3rd, but I could be completely wrong lol

Oh man that's a blast from the past

Agreed The fact that he basically pigeonholed them into the Giants, who cannot possibly trade for him with Eli on the roster, complicates this beyond belief

Agreed I think it's an interesting twist Does he pull a leveon bell? Who knows

Riiiiiiight.

Eli means they aren't trading for any QB starter.

He signed 4 years and about 90 million with 32 guaranteed He's not that underpaid Agreed Unless they are walking into a ready made team with a bunch of talent on cheap deals, they tend to suck up too much cap space Look how the falcons and Ravens fell apart after signing their QBs

At least I'm gung home and argumentative on one account and one account only ?

He's just gonna play for the Yankees With all their injuries right now he's probably a MLB starter for them ?

Agreed It's going to be tough for them though Letting him walk gets you a comp pick or two i think As I said the problem is he's dictated where he wants to go already That murders trade value if it's only one place because you have nobody else bidding Why give up a kings random if you are the Giants, when you can just sign him next season? Their team is a trainwreck so there's no urgency to get him this season

Plans don't always work out, and you can't make a guy sign if he doesn't want to play for you anymore. Franchise tag only helps so much, as it's a big heap of guaranteed money, but usually makes the player disgruntled. It's especially tough when a guy wants a trade, but only gives limited (or 1) trade options, publicly. It's very disingenuous to me when a guy acts like he wants out at all costs, but only gives limited places he will be traded to. (Ab, melo and ad in basketball come to mind) Do you want out that bad? Or do you only want out bad enough that you'll go where you dictate?