A lot of Darby in the top 5, but I prefer Gilmore. Darby has looked mortal the last couple of weeks, though he's been better than we ever could have imagined this season (also, he's just a rookie so that's nice).
Top 5:
1.) McCoy
2.) Watkins
3.) Dareus
4.) Incognito
5.) Tyrod (he's not the best talent but I think he's one of most valuable players given what we look like without him)
honorable mentions: Cordy, Wood, Darby, Karlos, Hughes (the penalties are awful, though)
Bottom 5
1.) EJ
2.) Duke Williams
3.) John Miller
4.) IK
5.) Carpenter