jletha

Fales of San Jose State, some people say he is going to be the best guy in the class. Theres a lot of top quality talent next year. This year is full of guys that you have to convince yourself in. I would much rather wait until the 2nd round or 3rd and take whos there. Reaching is going to be such a mistake this year I think. I do not want to end up in a Blaine Gabbert situation. He is by far the worst QB in the league and Jacksonville was stuck with him last year and missed out on the QBs last draft. I would advocate for not taking any QB at 8, even if Geno is there. There are so many holes on this team that we are going to bomb anyway. if were going to have a top 10 pick no matter what next year it makes more sense to use that pick on a QB when the QBs are much better, than using this years top 10 pick on a QB and reaching.

McCarron is definitely not 2nd to 3rd round talent. He is without a doubt 1st rounder

Thank you for making this post. This is the smartest post I have seen on here and it what Ive been trying to tell my friends. We need to scrap this year and focus on 2014 really. Use this year to fill in holes (we have many) with high draft choices that are not QBs. Use the cap space to extend Byrd, sign Spiller and Wood and then in 2014 go after a top QB with out inevitably high draft choice and use the rest of the cap space to fill in more holes. Reaching on a QB this year and leaving many holes to try to fill in at other positions next year is not the right approach when you look at the quality of the QBs coming out next year.

if Geno isnt there at 8 then take him but dont move up. Next years QBs are so much better. I know nobody wants to suffer through another losing season with Tavaris Jackson at the helm but if we get a top 10 pick next year the top 4 QBs that are projected to come out will have better grades than Geno does this year. Just wait it out and dont give up too much for this guy. We have too many other holes on this team that need filling.

I think itd be smart to wait this year out with Jackson (or if we bring someone else in to compete) and go for 2014. I think thats what this staff is thinking too. All of the top guys next year, assuming Manziel comes out, will have higher grades than anyone this year and I really dont want to be stuck with the situation where we win 4-6 games but drafted Nassib early in the second or traded up into the first to get him and have a top ten pick next year but dont draft one of these guys in order to give Nassib another chance. I basically dont want to have Brandon Weeden 2.0 on my team. The Browns know he isnt the guy but theyve got another year before they give up. Lucky for them the QBs suck this year but I dont want that to be us next year.

Well everyone said he would probably be a guard anyway and he wasnt the same after the injury last year. This years draft is very good for O-line and if a good tackle is there I say we take him. if its a guard then maybe Glenn Stays outside.

I actually dont really want to take any of those. With losing Rinehart and Levitre, my idea of the plans have changed. I think the staff is making this a two year project. They didnt like any FA QB that was reasonable to obtain and they dont love any of the QBs in the draft. I think we go O-lineman this year at 8 and slide Glenn to guard to fill our new hole at O-line. Then we take a LB or WR in the second unless we get a descent WR in the rest of FA. I dont see us risking ending up with a QB nobody on the staff believes in because he was the best this year and then sucking anyway and getting another top 10 spot and missing out on the McCarron, Bridgewater, Manziel, Murray draft to give whoever we have (EJ, Nassib, etc.) one more year in the system. I think they ride it out with TJack and maybe a 3rd or 4th round QB selection to compete and then go all in next FA and draft period. I honestly think they were gonna ride it out with Fitz or at least let him really compete ( and probably win) if he would have re-strcutred but he wouldnt. I think they told him "were gonna ride it out at QB this year and you can be apart of it if you restructure, otherwise were going with TJax." and he chose to not restructure and we cut him. Signing TJacks gave us some leverage in talking to Fitz so it wasnt like if we cut him we literally had no one. I am usually wrong but this is what I think.

I actually dont really want to take any of those. With losing Rinehart and Levitre, my idea of the plans have changed. I think the staff is making this a two year project. They didnt like any FA QB that was reasonable to obtain and they dont love any of the QBs in the draft. I think we go O-lineman this year at 8 and slide Glenn to guard to fill our new hole at O-line. Then we take a LB or WR in the second unless we get a descent WR in the rest of FA. I dont see us risking ending up with a QB nobody on the staff believes in because he was the best this year and then sucking anyway and getting another top 10 spot and missing out on the McCarron, Bridgewater, Manziel, Murray draft to give whoever we have (EJ, Nassib, etc.) one more year in the system. I think they ride it out with TJack and maybe a 3rd or 4th round QB selection to compete and then go all in next FA and draft period. I honestly think they were gonna ride it out with Fitz or at least let him really compete ( and probably win) if he would have re-strcutred but he wouldnt. I think they told him "were gonna ride it out at QB this year and you can be apart of it if you restructure, otherwise were going with TJax." and he chose to not restructure and we cut him. Signing TJacks gave us some leverage in talking to Fitz so it wasnt like if we cut him we literally had no one. I am usually wrong but this is what I think.