The problem with these shows nowadays is that they don't even know what they are arguing about. They take whatever is the latest hot-take on social media and ride it without actually getting any factual information.
Consider Tim Hasselbeck after the bills ran all over the raiders and then saying that the reason why Allen had such a good day was because they couldn't run the ball against them and he had to be "reckless" to move the football. It makes absolutely no sense any which way you slice it.