Which Class of 2018 QB Will Win a Super Bowl First? Will Go to the Super Bowl First?

[Gregg]

1 minute ago, MJS said:

I think Jackson is already going into the downswing of his career. What makes him special are his legs. He is a good passer as well, but without the threat of his legs, which will become less and less special as the years pass, he just won't have the ability to get it done. That's how I see it.

Allen will play his entire career in Buffalo.

 

I hope I am wrong about this, but I don't see Allen going to the Super Bowl with the Bills until there is a change with the FO. They have had 9 years and still can't get there. What's worse is it feels like the Bills are declining this year.

[Mikie2times]

-Darnold will Implode in the postseason 

-Jackson will implode in the postseason 

-Allen has no support 

 

So my guess is Baker

[MJS]

1 minute ago, Gregg said:

I hope I am wrong about this, but I don't see Allen going to the Super Bowl with the Bills until there is a change with the FO. They have had 9 years and still can't get there. What's worse is it feels like the Bills are declining this year.

Maybe there is a front office change at some point. But they'll never let Allen go.

 

It's also normal for teams, even with elite QBs, to have down years here and there as iterations of the teams age out and you have to have soft rebuilds.

[Buffalo716]

51 minutes ago, GoBills808 said:

ok so immediately Harbaugh won a SB w Flacco on a playoff heater that wasn't half as good as Allen's in 2021 so we can dismiss the idea that McDermott does more w less outright

 

as for Lamar, you realize he's bad in the playoffs...not just not good, but outright bad. talking 10TDs/7INTs 60%comp w 6 lost fumbles bad

I understand that lol I'm a stat King I know them all 

 

You're not dragging out any stats I don't know my friend 

 

Second of all Ravens team that won a Super bowl had 6 or 7 pro bowlers on it... The Ravens have the most pro bowlers since 2020 in the NFL.. they had like 12 in 2019 and 7 in 2020 and consistently been at the top

 

The Buffalo Bills do not have seven pro bowlers now..  the Ravens team that won a Superbowl with flacco has more pro bowlers than what the bills had in 2020-2021 or 2022... Not counting alternative pro bowlers which don't count

 

The Ravens had like 7 the year they won the Super bowl.. the bills still don't have that 

 

On paper the Ravens had had more talented teams than us since 2020... They don't win anything an underachieve...

 

Sean McDermott doesn't have one pro bowl player on defense right now and has a top 10 overall statistically in defense and we're eight and four and an AFC favorite to go to the Super bowl 

 

He's not taking diamonds and turning them into copper.. Sean has always maximized our talent he literally gets the most out of 5th 6th 7th round picks all the time

 

Everybody's go back to games from 4 years ago.. but we lost to eventual Super bowl champions barely... We're not losing by two touchdowns.. if the Chiefs had a better coaching staff and a better roster and they barely beat us in the playoffs?

 

Maybe our coaching staff did a pretty good job actually.. McDermott has outcoached Andy Reid multiple times over the years and we've won like four or five straight against the Chiefs and the regular season 

 

You can't even make the postseason if you don't do good in the regular season... Beating Andy Reid four straight times is very impressive coaching

 

The Ravens have the most pro bowlers in the NFL since 2020.. the bills aren't in the top four

 

Lamar is 1-4 against mahomes with very talented rosters with a coach you consider better 

 

The bills have won five straight in the regular season with less talent .. it's because our coaching is pretty dang good

Edited 38 minutes ago by Buffalo716

[Seventeen]

On 12/4/2025 at 3:23 PM, The Frankish Reich said:

Or he'll be a crypto bro who buys the Cardinals and signs free agent Josh Allen to do a late-career Elway.

 

Josh Rosen is currently attending the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School of Business, where he is pursuing a Master's degree in Business Administration. After his NFL career took him to multiple teams, he has shifted his focus to a business education. 

 

From Wiki ... 

 

Rosen is the maternal great-great-great-grandson of Joseph Wharton, the co-founder of Bethlehem Steel and founder of the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, which was named in his honor. Rosen is named after another ancestor, Joshua Ballinger Lippincott, who founded publishing house J. B. Lippincott & Co.

 

Just another hungry MBA candidate scraping by ...