Thurman#1 Posted September 3 Posted September 3 On 9/1/2025 at 2:43 AM, Captain Hindsight said: Maye won one game that he started and finished. I get that team wasn’t good and coaching was worse, but I didn’t see a dude elevate his team like some of the elite guys Very fair that he didn't elevate the team, but he was a rookie. Josh Allen didn't elevate this team as a rookie. Our offense was 30th out of 32 that year. The best passing game that year probably belonged to Matt Barkley. More, wins are not a stat that you should judge a QB by, particularly a rookie on a truly crappy team. You judge a QB by how he played. Maye played pretty damn well for a rookie. I mean, I still have enough leftover hatred for the Pats that I hope I'm wrong, and he still has a ton to prove but he looked good to me. Quote
Captain Hindsight Posted September 3 Posted September 3 6 hours ago, Thurman#1 said: Very fair that he didn't elevate the team, but he was a rookie. Josh Allen didn't elevate this team as a rookie. Our offense was 30th out of 32 that year. The best passing game that year probably belonged to Matt Barkley. More, wins are not a stat that you should judge a QB by, particularly a rookie on a truly crappy team. You judge a QB by how he played. Maye played pretty damn well for a rookie. I mean, I still have enough leftover hatred for the Pats that I hope I'm wrong, and he still has a ton to prove but he looked good to me. I'm not saying he should have won more games, that team was awful last year. But I just didnt see the eye popping plays that everyone is acting like he made all year. The one "highlight" they constantly show is him keeping a play alive against the Titans (who had the number one overall pick this year) and throwing a TD. Like yeah, great play but do I think he going to be as good as Daniels, Nix or Williams or Penix? No, I don't. I actually think McCarthy is going to be the best of them all purely because of who his coach is Quote
boyst Posted September 3 Posted September 3 If we are amazed he's still out there, again, so is Justin Simmons. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.