Jump to content

Stevie Jackson OR Vincent Jackson?


Stevie Johnson OR Vincent Jackson?  

74 members have voted

  1. 1. Who would you rather have if you could have just one?



Recommended Posts

Jackson is a more talented receiver but I can't help but want Stevie back. I know about his problems with celebrations after touchdowns, but that does not take back how he has totally embraced the city of Buffalo and made it his home. He has been that way since day one and it's obvious to me that he loves the players, the fans, the team, the entire city and what it stands for and he wants to stay. Please don't confuse immiturity with not being a team player or with not loving his team. That is totally absurd.

Vincent Jackson is super talented. That is a fact. He is also selfish to the 10th power and when he held out as long as he could last year, I was done with the guy. Totally not a team player. Never has been and never will be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that Vincent Jackson is super talented. And there are in fact several other FA WR's who may be available. Assuming we can have only one, doesn't it make sense to at least shop around and find out if one of these guys might be interested in playing here? Let's get the most bang for our buck...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that Vincent Jackson is super talented. And there are in fact several other FA WR's who may be available. Assuming we can have only one, doesn't it make sense to at least shop around and find out if one of these guys might be interested in playing here? Let's get the most bang for our buck...

sure, but that has nothing to do with the poll question. it was simple. if you could just choose one, would you want johnson or jackson.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sure, but that has nothing to do with the poll question. it was simple. if you could just choose one, would you want johnson or jackson.

 

 

I used Vincent Jackson as such because right now he seems likely to be available, and as we both agree is super talented (certainly equal to or better than Stevie Johnson and minus all the drama) and depending on co$t might be a wiser choice. Some people will feel different for different reasons... I am curious how deep the support for Stevie is around here?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used Vincent Jackson as such because right now he seems likely to be available, and as we both agree is super talented (certainly equal to or better than Stevie Johnson and minus all the drama) and depending on co$t might be a wiser choice. Some people will feel different for different reasons... I am curious how deep the support for Stevie is around here?

 

Vjax is SJ without the drama? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

let's be clear. jackson is faster, bigger, stronger....a true number one. steive might be a number one but that has yet to be proven. still, i want stevie. he wants to be here. that means a lot to me. loyalty. jackson is a punk who is only playing for money. could care less where he plays. just my opinion obviously but it's based on what i've seen over the last three years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both are children. As are Dwayne Bowe and Desean Jackson, the other top WR free agents. Regardless, Jackson won't sign in Buffalo, we just don't land the guys who are in demand.

Robert Meachem? Or would he be insane to leave that Saints offense?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both are children. As are Dwayne Bowe and Desean Jackson, the other top WR free agents. Regardless, Jackson won't sign in Buffalo, we just don't land the guys who are in demand.

Robert Meachem? Or would he be insane to leave that Saints offense?

Funny how many wideouts are head cases, isn' it?

 

I wonder if it has to do with the constant professional fear of decapitation.

 

Anyways to the OP, for the sake of this little exercise, we're assuming that each player would come at equal cost?

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, it comes with the territory, I guess. Oh to see the likes of another Andre Reed.

no kidding. after watching easley in preseason, i made the remark to one of my friends that he reminded me of a young eric moulds. (he'd need to bulk up a little of course). i know it was only a preseason game but he dominated the first half of action against jacksonville and gave me hope of what he could be...then of course the mysterious illness and the rest is history. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Or James Lofton.

or don beebe. heck, i'd take back peerless price now...at least the price of 2002 with his breakout season when he went deep early and often with bledsoe. heck, i'd take bucky brooks right now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, it comes with the territory, I guess. Oh to see the likes of another Andre Reed.

 

no kidding. after watching easley in preseason, i made the remark to one of my friends that he reminded me of a young eric moulds.

 

Or James Lofton.

 

or don beebe. heck, i'd take back peerless price now…

Kwame Cavil anyone?

 

Anyways, I am glad that Easley has recovered from that chicken wing bone which perforated his intestines.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd take Stevie in a heart beat. I know VJ is great but he's not without incident either. So for what it's worth, i'd rather have the guy that's been here and produced back to back 1,000 yard seasons and already has a repor with Fitz. But I'd try and make sure to get both.

 

As far as Reed or Lofton, neither were without incident either. Reed was a major cry baby, especially at the end of his career. Wasn't Lofton involved with some off the field issues, beating his wife or something like that?

 

Just saying, none of these players are without incident, most have some issue here or there.

Edited by mrags
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...