1- john elway- the total package qb, run, throw, tough , greatest come from behind qb of all time. went to 4 superbowls. won 2.
2- tom brady- hate to say it but its true. he can will his team to victory with mediocre weapons, fiery, smart, 3 superbowl victory.
3- dan marino- greatest passer of all time, quickest release, fiery and vocal. rating would be higher if he won the big games.
4- joe montana- joe cool had ice in his veins, smart, can make all the throws, can come from behind, a winner.
5- peyton manning- smartest qb of all time and great passer.
6- brett farve- the ironman of football. greatest improvisor, quick release, nice arm, vocal and fiery. went to 2 superbowls. won 1
7- jim kelly- - toughest SOB that ever played the position( hed get plastered and get right back up) strong arm, fiery and vocal. rating would be in top 3 had it not been for 4 in a row( i dont want to say the words and u know why) , playing in arguably the worst weather in the NFL, and having to give the ball to thurman thomas.
8- john unitas
9- troy aikmen
10- warren moon