DrDawkinstein

The real question is: would you replace McDermott with him?

I think if he tried just making the catch and happy to get to the 1 yard line, he probably gets a catch. I think his trying to turn up field as he was catching the ball really worked against him and ended up making him bobble it. Never really caught it solidly. I dont blame him at all for trying to get into the endzone, just sayin, that seems to be what happened.

No it didnt. It was moving the whole time. He never secured it. He wasnt adjusting the ball in a possessed cradle, he was trying to pin it as it was sliding down his arm/body. I think if there was any other angle of this, it would clear it up for everyone.

We are VERY heightened, Amari. Especially since NY became a legal state.

And the announcers probably do understand the rule, but it gives them something to talk about as they need to fill 3 hours, AND acting like its tough to tell lets them cover their butts for when they make the wrong call while covering the game. Plus, the old players like Aikman and the like love complaining about new/modern rules. The ol "back in my day" and "yelling at clouds". Ok, but this hit the ground after sliding down his body because he never possessed it. So incomplete according to your rule too. edit: apologies, it never hit the ground, he did end up gathering possession but it was well after he was out of bounds.

He never had possession. Not with the first foot down, or second, or third. The ball was always moving down his body and sliding out of his arm. He never possessed it for it to be a TD by crossing the plane, regardless of feet down.

Hopefully not KC, but my money is on KC.

Coaches made the adjustments. Credit to them there. But just shows even more how we have the talent to blow teams out, but the poor game plans and play calls of the coaches hold this team back at times.

He's trying to figure out how to let them score 2 quick touchdowns so he can bring back his "victories by 6pts or less" streak.

Pretty common for interior LBs who always go up against Guards with a head of steam. Even worse that we use small LBs.

WTF happened on that review? I missed 5 minutes. They challenged Kincaid's catch, but we got the catch, but their challenge was successful?

Talent baling out coaching

Even in our rebuilding/transition year we are way more talented than Tennessee.

I'm pirating today and my feed just froze and I'm seriously considering just closing the laptop and doing something actually productive. McDermott is ruining my weekend.

Wait til you see how we do against screens!

Josh and the talent saving McD's job again. "Look at that awesome regular season record!"

Add Mason Rudolph to McD's list. Pathetic.

How bout now?

Sloppy, undisciplined, unprepared, horrible technique...

Every game we arent playing Miami.

McDermott LOVES making bad QBs look great.

Yeah, he has been very disappointing. Brady might be something, someday, somewhere. But the whole crew has to go.

We are wasting Josh's best years on McDermott. He has to go.

This thread reeks of... Pure Speculation.

Given how McD likes to let guys like Easton Stick, Mike White, Zach WIlson, a struggling Russell Wilson, etc all have career days against the Bills, dont count out Rudolph (or Levis).