Once again i see this argument and it is filled with holes. How can you compare a rookie QB to guys who have been in the league over 8 years and are at the top of their game? That sir is illogicial.
A rookie QB will make a line look like ****. If you watch Brady, Brees or Manning they change the coverage on a given pass play based upon what the defense is doing. If they see a rush coming they change the coverage to give them more time to make a play. People get so hung up on Arm Strength and whatever but recognizing Defenses and shifting your offense to get around it makes a QB great. A rookie QB will not do this. they dont' have the experience or the knowledge yet.