The arguments are there every week, and I can understand why. Maybe because he has a strong arm, maybe because he was a first (and 2nd) round pick, maybe because they are eternal optimists, I don't know. We can argue all day about this and not come to a conesenus. I remember the "it" thread a few weeks ago and the debate that it created.
It isn't fair to compare JP to Brady, Palmer, Manning, etc. He will never be half as good as any of those guys. You know what he is lacking...the personality to be an NFL QB. Just listen to him at a press conference, he sounds like an idiot. Watch him interact with his teammates, he doesn't. JP needs to be the Alpha Dog and he can't be, he doesn't have it in him.
When was the last time you saw JP on the sidelines trying to rally his troops?
When was the last time you saw JP get in a receivers face for making a mistake?
When was the last time you saw JP cuss out a lineman for missing an assignment?
It is JPs job to make the guys around him better. It is his responsibility to not let thos guys make the same mistakes over and over. The other players around him have to NOT WANT to let JP down.
For those of you that ae convinced that he need more time, what has he done to prove that? What do you see in him that shows he has tha makings of a real QB?