Success
-
Posts
9,756 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Posts posted by Success
-
-
If you draft a guy at 10, he has to start.
-
I'm with you....Brady >>> Manning...and it's not even close.....remember also, Brady was a missed xtra point away to bring the 2015 AFC Championship to OT in Denver...vs that incredible D............or how Manning crumbled in the SB vs Seattle, putting up 8 pts...then the very next year, Brady put up 28....Butler made the play of course, but being down 10 pts vs that D and coming back is telling ...I couldn't imagine Manning making that comeback....or vs Atlanta this year....
The entire legion of boom needed surgery when the 4th quarter started. Not the same D that Manning faced.
-
Lets play a round of Questions:
1. Who are the elite WR's and RB's Brady played most his career with and won 5 SB's with? NONE except 1 SB win with Gronk.
2. Who are the elite WR's, TE's and RB's Montana played most his career with and won 4 SB's with? GOAT Rice, Taylor, Clark, Jones, Craig, Waters
3. Who are the elite WR's, TE's, and RB's Manning played with most his career and won 2 SB's with? HOF Harrison, possible future HOF Wayne, EDGE, Clark, Thomas, Welker, Thomas.
What kind of weather did each play most their home careers in:
1. Brady - Awful outside conditions for 16 years in New England plus games in bad weather divisional stadiums twice a year.
2. Montana - Sunny CA with some occasional rain.
3. Manning - Cushy dome with a short stop in Denver.
Brady won 3 SB titles in 4 seasons throwing to scrubs who couldn't make it as starters on other teams. He's now won 2 in the last 3 despite having an underwhelming cast of skill players not named Gronk and Gronk didn't even play in the post season during this years SB run. And now Brady is the hands down favorite to win again next year which would be the SECOND time he would have won 3 SB's in 4 seasons if he does.
I wont make a stink about people putting Montana up there, because before Brady he was the GOAT IMO. But Brady crushes Manning who accomplished far less with more riches of talent around him. Even Manning's 2nd SB title, they won INSPITE of Manning who put up the single worst performance of a QB of all the winners in SB history after being one of the lowest rated passers in the NFL all that season. So much so Trevor almost took his job.
You're cherry picking and ignoring the biggest factor of all - Brady played under the greatest coach of all time.
-
I don't get the Manning love...he was absolutely great in the regular season...but man, when the pressure was on, he, more often than not , crumbled miserably.....9 times he had a 1 and done...9!
We can't also ignore the fact the for most of his career, he played in a cozy dome.....that certainly helped the stats....
And finally, his 2nd SB was on the back of a great Denver defense.....he was one of the worst QB in the NFL that year.....
It's a team game. I remember most of those playoff exits, and only a few were on Manning. He didn't often get much help, and played under 5 different coaches.
I still think Brady is the goat, but too much is made of the ring count. Brady wouldn't have 5 on another team, and BB wouldn't only have 2 if Manning was his QB this whole time.
-
Could it be that because the supplements Brady consumes now were not available then?
General question
When it comes to Brady* and Manning, which QB did more with less?
I know that's set up for a "Brady" answer, but it's Manning. Brady had better defenses, and most importantly, the greatest coach of all time.
-
Brady is never out of a game.
Maybe we play him too much. But I never feel comfortable with any lead against him, and I always feel like he's going to score when he gets the ball.
No one else like that. I can't remember feeling that way watching Montana.
-
How do we even know?Its simple really, They can't evaluate QB's worth a damn
They have to try more. Qb's are the biggest crapshoot in the draft.
-
I'll be disappointed if they don't snag a qb in the 1st 3 rounds or so this year.
Sad draft history. Hard to figure out why we have so often devalued the most important position.
-
The Bills need a WR 2... They have all the other ones.
Yep. Pretty sure they're eyeing the draft for that #2 also.
-
if your going that route. Todays AFC championship game would be the same as the nfl championship game. Otto went to 10. Brady has been to 11.
Seriously? You post here too?
-
The beatings QB's took in past eras were more brutal than what Brady and current QB's have had to deal with, and it's not even close.
Only in the sense that some hits are now against the rules. But defenders today are bigger, stronger and faster. They hit harder than the defenders of yesteryear.
-
I think Brady is the best, and don't buy the powder puff thing. He takes a beating sometimes, and seems to actually get better the more he gets hit. He was getting pounded in the Super Bowl.
-
Pretty sure this signing means we're good at WR now
At least we Bills fans never lose our robust sense of humor.
-
.if this isnt a clear sign we are going wr or howard at 10 then i dont know what is..
Depends. We might end up signing even more guys before the draft. A lot still has to play out.
-
That's ridiculous. What about McCoy doesn't fit!
-
Please. As though Brown is the best guy we're going to pick up.Hard to believe considering Buffalo has used 2 1sts on Watkins, a 2nd on Woods, and a 3rd on Goodwin in the past 4 drafts.
If you don't draft well in this league the ramifications almost put you in a continued downward spiral. Coming out of it is exceptionally difficult and UFA can't make up for it.
Jarrett Boykin, Justin Hunter, Walt Powell, Greg Salas, Leonard Hankerson, Dezmin Lewis, Kolby Listenbee, Percy Harvin, and Brandon Tate were not acquisitions that made Whaley look like he knew what he was doing there.
And now, they've removed Woods and Goodwin from the equation. The likelihood after Philly Brown was signed that group improves is slim.
Bad injury luck last year. Might be a good idea to give the offseason more than a week.
-
There are very few WRs left in FA, and a draft pick is a complete wildcard in year 1. As it stands now, it's a fact.
No, it isn't. We have no idea right now what our final group will look like. It's a meaningless hot take.
-
Whaley has assembled possibly the worst WR corps in the league.
I don't really get how a comment like this is even possible a week into free agency and over a month before the draft.
-
Interesting speculation on First Take about BB going all in because he's thinking of retiring soon.
He is making a few uncharacteristic moves. Things will be a lot more fun when McDaniels is their coach.
-
Butler is not going anywhere....I can't picture any team giving up a 1st round pick and paying him a top 10 CB salary....He'll play in NE at the $3.91 Million tender...his only leverage is to hold out, but I can't picture him passing on almost 4 million....
Man, that is going to sting - playing across from a guy you think you're better than, who is getting paid almost $10 million more.
-
It's nice to imagine a day when I don't care at all what the patriots do.
-
The Gilmore deal is still surprising to me. BB never overpays like that, and Gilmore doesn't seem like his kind of guy. Really makes you wonder.
-
i have no doubt this will happen. Other teams are somehow hypnotized by them.
"These aren't the droids you're looking for..."
-
Hope he holds out
Tom Brady-The Greatest of His Era, Not All-Time
in The Stadium Wall Archives
Posted
Well, yeah. Manning was one of the best at comebacks. Including a few big ones against the Pats.