"The girl allegedly beaten has nothing out there that suggests she was even beaten." this is what happens with domestic violence. abusers have such control over their partner that they can make them do whatever they want.
"The girls in the pic dont even look like the same person" come on dude, seriously? in the first pic she's modelled up. in the second she's been beaten to a bloody pulp.
"He has no history of this behavior" lol no kidding. if he did, he wouldn't be in the league any more.
"the beaten girls IG has no reference to McCoy and her even knowing each other" ask yourself...if your partner was beating you, would you want to post a picture of yourself with them?
"This is what is wrong with society...more than 90% of the stuff online is fake...its probably even worse than that...and yet people take all this stuff as true first before questioning it. I am dumbfounded how many people are jumping to the conclusion this is real with a complete lack of evidence this event even happened."
by the same token, it's completely reckless to assume that it's fake. if everyone cries bs every time a DV victim comes forward, they'll never find the courage to speak up. in fact, she never did. her friend had to do it for her.
i'm by no means accusing shady of anything yet, either. i'm just providing the counter argument here. let's just see how it plays out without leaning either way.