Miyagi-Do Karate
-
Posts
32,330 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Posts posted by Miyagi-Do Karate
-
-
I completely agree. Or Cousins.
TJ Graham is going to amount to a ridiculous 3rd round selection. His chances of succeeding at this level are remote other than as a 4th/5th role playing WR with very limited utility.
Of course there are those here that already know he's going to be a hall of famer. lol
I wouldn't have taken a QB in rounds 1 or 2, but you're right, in 3, rather than Graham, they should have gone with Wilson or Cousins.
Drafting a QB in the 3rd round is usually a waste. In the 3rd, you can get a legit position player starter at almost any position. But by the 3rd, the odds of getting a starting QB go way down, unless you magically win the lottery (e.g., Brady).
The odds of guys like Mallett, Cousins, and Wilson becoming star QB's ever is pretty slim, IMO. The odds of TJ Graham being a starting slot receiver for this team within the next 2 years are pretty good.
-
Seriously?
There is no way in hell that any casual observer or even complete fanatic should have a leg up in evaluating NFL talent over a GM or HC getting paid millions to do their respective jobs! No matter how long they have been watching the team. Its not just the GM / HC doing the evaluations,its not just 2 guys, its an entire staff of 18-20 assistant coaches and another staff of scouts.
This is kinda why we all knew Jauron was a complete fool. Jauron himself was an ex NFL player and DB, you would think he could evaluate that position better then he did. Not to mention repeatedly drafting DB's year after year, and then drafting Aaron Maybin!! When he should have been searching for that one great mike for his tampon 2.
This is what film study is for, good coaches would go back to watch college film and then to everything present to break down a players ability and evaluate them properly. Watching every move and every play. But then, it also helps to know and understand what you are watching. The assistants and scouts shouldn't be the only ones watching the film.
Film study is what made Bill Belichick so great. It was in his attention to detail in watching film of opposing offenses and their tendencies. Although it seems like the old master has slipped somewhat recently, his team still went to the big dance last year. Plus his team has been in the playoffs for as long as Buffalo has been out of the playoffs.
NFN, but when you have fans that are more knowledgeable about the players then the current coaching regime, even from day one, then there is a serious problem. Kinda why I'm here writing about it
You underestimate the knowledgable fan. There's sometimes no substitute for seeing a guy play every snap for 5 years, as opposed to some newbie hire and his entire staff watching a bunch of film and making major scheme and roster decisions in a few weeks without any context.
Plus, it's kind of like Moneyball-- sometimes the "experts" aren't really experts.
-
Mallet looked ok but it's tough to judge since the Pats OLine looks brutal, at best.
And Bell took a beating for the Eagles. Didnt even start, finally came in in the 2nd half (I believe), and as the announcers were talking about him sliding down the chart he gets flagged for a bad penalty and kills their drive. LOL!!!
Honestly, I feel bad for Bell. As I understand his contract, what could happen is he bombs for one season, they cut him (and he gets no further guaranteed pay), and he could be out of the league like that.
-
This is where we, as fans, have an advantage. You have to remember that the new regimes that come in aren't long-time fans of the team. This is a problem when it comes to evaluating talent quickly.
As fans, we've watched every single game (many live), and have seen players play in real-game situations against a variety of opponents and over long stretches of time. Believe it or not, knowledgeable fans probably have a leg-up on a new regime that comes in and has a short period of time to review some game tape and make quick roster decisions.
One example: Jabari Greer. I think most fans saw his potential back from day 1, after seeing him play through pre-seasons and in limited game action as a nickel and dime back. Yet it took at least 2 years before Jauron and co. figured it out and started him.
-
What I find interesting is that nearly everyone on this board appears so surprised, yet James Welker of ESPN said "The move isn't a surprise."
I love it when reporters and pundits have 20/20 hindsight about foresight they never made public. Color this fan very surprised--all indicators were up for Merriman to have a successful season and I heard nothing from the coaches to indicate otherwise.
haha-- James Welker isn't surprised because he doesn't follow the team and probably thought Merriman was still on IR.
This is a total shock to everyone, even those, like me, who though Merriman looked mediocre in the pre-season games.
-
Why are we so anti depth? Moore better develop into something solid...
because we are one of the least injured teams in the NFL, of course.
-
I've found the replacement refs aren't getting the "judgment" calls right--stuff that comes with years of experience.
The holds, PI, even false starts (you can move your head and it isn't always a false start)....that stuff boils down to judgment and the replacements just aren't going to get it.
-
this thread has some serious F5/Pat Moran potential. I want answers!!
-
Why not keep him solely based on his potential, locker room presence, and as a situational pass rush guy?
-
I have yet to see "Hesher", but I agree with you and JR, JGL is really showing how talented he is.
This is also turning out to be quite a year for JGL. He's got "Premium Rush" out at the end of the month, he'll be alongside Bruce Willis in "Looper" in September, and then he'll be Robert Todd Lincoln in Steven Spielberg's biopic "Lincoln" in November.
Glad you enjoyed TDKR, JR. I don't know why it has gotten many criticisms from some people either.
didn't know about the Lincoln biopic--I will definitely have to see it.
Mark, I read your post earlier in the thread, and we were in total agreement on the film. I wonder if people who were so hyped up for this movie had unrealistic expectations or something, and thus came away disappointed. I don't know how anyone can rip such a wonderful plot (with good twists), and great acting.
-
Glad you saw it...sounds like you felt about it as I did. Agree about the acting...JG-L is one of the top 10 best character actors in Hollywood, and on my list he's probably top 5. His body of work shows a TON of versatility...he's able to expertly portray the helpless romantic greeting card writer in "500 Days of Summer", to the pot smoking, hell raising "Hesher", to the heartless, cavalier thug with the itchy trigger finger in "Killshot". I really wonder if people are taking note of his resume here, cause it's very impressive.
Versatile is great way to describe JGL. When TDKR started, I was shocked that he was cast as the beat cop--didn't think it was a good fit. I was wrong--he pulled it off beautifully.
-
Little behind here, but finally saw TDKR last night.
I had heard some folks criticize it. I am surprised.
Thought the story was absolutely compelling, the acting (esp by Hathaway and Gordon-Leavitt) well-done, and the ending perfect.
Added bonus--much of the filming was done right by my building in downtown Pittsburgh, so it was cool to see all the places I know in the movie.
-
Just flipped through this thread to see what has transpired. As usual, it's nice to see such an alarming mix of schizophrenia and paranoia.
-
I am going to order a chan shirt--hilarious.
-
1) I don't like re-watching the Oilers comeback game when it's on TV because you have to sit through that horrendous first half. Not sure I could stomach that again (unless I had perfect knowledge of the outcome)
2) I was at the Jax/Bills Flutie TD-run game--and that was magical. Wouldn't mind going back and seeing that one again.
-
I'm not expecting much. Still aren't game planning, and probably playing around with different things, so don't really have an opinion.
Next week is when I'll really pay attention.
Concur. I expect to be bored.
And I hope no injuries.
-
very exciting news for the 2013-14 incoming freshman class...this kid sounds like a stud at guard....plus he plays hockey for the sabres????
Good find. Getting excited about this year already--we should be solid as anything for the next 3 years.
-
Silly. Wasn't this tried like 10 years ago by a bunch of newspapers and failed miserably?
-
Morrison back to his real position/43defense, right? If so, not only will he be safe but I fully expect him to log 80+ tackles in a starting role. He's ready to go this year and'll be a surprise for us. (especially @TBD apparently)
Why do peeps not like him so much? Is it because everyone's in love with Favre-crushing Moats, and he's competing for a valuable roster spot? Are we relegating him to a backup role?
Help me out on this one, guys...
Albeit in limited action last year, Morrison looked slow, lost, and old.
I am hoping that was due to playing out of position and being injured--but it didn't inspire confidence.
-
It was a blast listening to Ross Tucker this a.m. on SiriusXM NFL Radio on my way into the office. He was running through the Jets' skill players on offense and concluded they are probably "bottom 5" in the NFL in that regard.
Ross' partner on the show, Giants' play-by-play guy Bob Papa, couldn't come up with a decent argument in rebuttal, other that to surmise Dustin Keller at TE is probably underrated (with which Tucker agreed).
It brings into perspective all of the Tebow nonsense, Cromartie playing WR, and "secret" wildcat practices. The Jets know they stink on offense, and are trying to create some sort of buzz or fear heading into the season.
I can't wait for Sep. 9 to get here.
As much as I hate that team, "bottom 5"?
Santonio Holmes is a top-10 receiver. Kerley is a really good slot guy. Shonne Greene, while inconsistent, is no slouch.
While Sanchez sucks, there are probably 10 starting QB's in the league worse than him (maybe--I'd have to count).
-
Is gibran hamdan on the team? That should answer your question.
-
Polamalu also cant throw the ball.. how are they going to do anything on offense with 200 lb offensive lineman and a QB who cant throw?
What makes you think Polamalu can't throw? I was just reading his wiki page, and the guy played both ways in high school, and was a first-team all-state RB, and was also a star high school baseball and basketball player. I would venture to guess that especially as a star High School baseball player, he could throw a football.
But there would be little throwing needed-- I'd run a spread-read style offense with Polamalu.
He would get eaten alive in the trenches. Covering a WR is a small portion of what's required. He'd have to block Vince wilfork, suh, dareus...... Whoever. And shed blocks without any big guys eating space on the defensive line. you could just run on him, and even if hes good in coverage the qb should have 8-10 seconds on most plays.
for me its narrowed totally to can Cam tackle/be physical, or can Ware throw?
its the only way youd stand any chance of the game being remotely competitive, and even then its almost impossible.
I like ware a lot because he can hit, he can take on lineman, hes physical enough that youd hope at 260-270 he wouldnt just crumble when blocking. he played WR at a high level in high school so he has hands and some idea of routes possibly. the only spots he suffer terribly at are corner (still 4.5 speed and not totally foreign to play outside, and drops in coverage occasionally. could probably hold a guy for 2-3 seconds if 4-5 wares could pressure the qb fast), and center/guard with blocking DTs. With of course the question - can he throw?
DeMarcus Ware (or Cam) couldn't cover any WR in the league, let alone my team of Polamalus. We would kill you.
-
Troy Polamalu. He can tackle like a LB. He has the speed to play CB and Safety. He can catch the ball. He has a high IQ and is as tough as a lineman.
Honestly, to me, Polamalu is the no-brainer.
People who are proposing LT or Tebow or Roethlesberger are forgetting how hard it is to cover a WR. Polamalu can cover, and is no slouch at shedding offensive linemen.
-
I'd take the 50 or so lbs gap over the likely minimal gain in speed (especially at those guys ages)
Really has to be a TE, big qb, or 34 OLB for this.
How about some other defensive guys - Demarcus ware? Hes 6'4, 260+ and runs a 4.5
Very similar to cam but a question of ball skills vs tackling.
I can't see Ware covering guys downfield. I think you almost need a LB-safety tweener-- like a Brian Urlacher perhaps.
I would still think Polamalu or Reed (in their prime) would be better; I'd rather have the speed than the weight.
If you could only keep Byrd or Levitre who would pick and why?
in The Stadium Wall Archives
Posted
+1
I too refuse to play this game!
Sign them both.