I'm not a fan of those two at all, especially Schoop. That being said, I tend to agree with them on this point. I was very surprised at all the love EJ has been getting on this board. My eyes tell me he's improved, but still struggles making decisions, especially in the face of pressure. He may get away with that against second and third string defenses, but against starting defenses he's going to be in trouble. I also thing he still has a tendency to either sail balls or throw at receivers feet.
Don't get me wrong, I like EJ a lot and am very encouraged that he's playing better, but think he needs more time to improve and shouldn't be in the conversation for starting QB. At this point, I think they need to focus on Taylor and Cassell and get ready for the season and keep EJ on the bench for one more year, barring a catastrophe.