Jump to content

Which QB would you pick

Orton's Arm

By Orton's Arm
in The Stadium Wall Archives

 Share

  

58 members have voted

  1. 1. If you could choose one QB to lead the Bills' future, which would it be? Be sure to take into account whichever draft picks you'd have to use on him!

    • A QB who'd give this team some Luck.
      31
    • A QB who's going to hit defenses over the head with a Mallett
      11
    • A QB who's going to give defenses Fitz
      11
    • A QB who's going to give defenses something to Ponder
      0
    • A leader of a QB who's going to make the Locker room his own
      0
    • Other (please identify)
      5

Recommended Posts

Orton's Arm Veteran

Orton's Arm

Posted
Posted

I just want to know what everyone thinks. For those who envision an early pick like Luck or Mallett, also take into account the non-QB player you won't be able to draft due to using that top-5 pick on a QB!

DreReed83 RFA

DreReed83

Posted
Posted

I want Luck. If we can't get him, keep Fitz

 

We keep Fitz whether we draft a QB with our number 1 pick or not. I don't want to start a rookie QB and rush him. We draft a QB and sit him behind Fitz for another year or 2.

The Senator All Pro

The Senator

Posted
Posted

I voted 'Other' - instead opting to continue losing every game this year and next - because the guy I really really want is Oregon's Darron Thomas. When he finally comes out and is drafted into NFL, he will make Andy Luck look like chopped liver - you'll all see.

 

But in reality, I don't even want him - what I really want is for the Bills to lose all future games, in perpetuity, so that we can continue to have 20-30 more silly threads like this every week for the rest of time.

bobobonators All Pro

bobobonators

Posted
Posted

haha..i actually like how he worded the poll.

 

I'd like to see how Fitz finishes the year. if he's as strong as he's been so far, I wouldn't draft a QB in 2011 and instead focus on building the DL/LB/OL. this team has major holes it needs to fill, and picking a QB at one or two overall isn't going to do us much of anything w/o a supporting cast.

Sabre Bill Rookie

Sabre Bill

Posted
Posted

I understand the value of a "franchise QB", but a winning TEAM is more important. Fitz isn't Manning and maybe not Luck, but he isn't the biggest problem in town. Surround Fitz with bewtte players -- especially on defense -- and the playoff drought ends. Fitz take ya to the Super Bowl? OK, maybe not all by himself, so let's focus on the other leaks in the roof.

The Senator All Pro

The Senator

Posted
Posted

Why no Newton on the poll?

1) Because he coudln't carry Darron Thomas' jock strap (Neither could Andy Luck - that's why it's better to lose all this season AND next! B-) )

 

2) Because this is the TBD Stadium Wall, and we have very high ethical standards regarding whom we allow on the Bills' roster..

 

Newton scandal shows game stays same

 

Backup QB Cameron Newton arrested for stealing laptop, suspended from team

 

GO BILLSSS!!!!

 

It will be 'heaven' - in 2011!!!!! :beer:

oak tree 12 RFA

oak tree 12

Posted
Posted

I just want to know what everyone thinks. For those who envision an early pick like Luck or Mallett, also take into account the non-QB player you won't be able to draft due to using that top-5 pick on a QB!

 

if luck comes out there is no choice he will be the #1 pick over anyone in the draft including the other QB's available.

 

he is head and shoulders above any QB coming out and there are some great ones coming out but he is a very rare QB with the "IT" factor in spades.

High Mark Veteran

High Mark

Posted
Posted

If he is the next peyton manning and we finished say 3-13 and ended up with the #2 pick... i would trade whatever it takes.

I dont think there will ever be another Payton Manning, but IMO Luck is going to be as good as the Rodgers/Rivers/Roethisburger/Brees

 

And I would trade everything it took too.

BillsPhan RFA

BillsPhan

Posted
Posted

I just want to know what everyone thinks. For those who envision an early pick like Luck or Mallett, also take into account the non-QB player you won't be able to draft due to using that top-5 pick on a QB!

 

:worthy: Nice job with the name-puns!

 

I voted Luck, but I would have no problems with any of those other choices.

 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...