Which QB would you pick

[BillsPhan]

I dont think there will ever be another Payton Manning, but IMO Luck is going to be as good as the Rodgers/Rivers/Roethisburger/Brees

 

And I would trade everything it took too.

 

Yeah, there may never be another Payton Manning drafted number 1. But how do you explain Tom Brady getting drafted number 199 or there abouts??? And how do you explain the 1983 draft, that produced John Elway, Dan Marino and Jim Kelly, all three in the Hall of Fame today, in the same first round?? And how do you exlain the 2004 draft, that produced Eli Manning, certainly not the QB his brother is.....yet, but still a SB winner and SB MVP already in his young career, and Ben Roethlisberger, 2 TIME SB winner and one time SB MVP already in his young career, and Phillip Rivers, already one of the best gun-slingers in the NFL in his young career.

 

The truth is you can never say never about any player, or any draft year. That is because almost every draft year has one or two "sure-thing" high draft pick QB busts, and "after-thought" low draft pick successes. Lest we forget, the QB most people consider the very best in NFL history, Joe Montana, was taken in the 3rd round by the 49ers in the '79 draft!!

 

So you may think Andrew Luck is your only choice, but the truth of the matter is, the "Aaron Rogers" QB of this group, you know, the one that falls out of the top 10 for whatever reason and keeps falling all the way to the bottom of the first round?, maybe Locker, maybe Mallet, maybe Ponder, that guy might end up being the best of them all!!

Edited November 7, 2010 by BillsPhan

[Cannon]

Cam's the Man! A man among boys on the field, that's not going to change on the next level either. Plus could take him in the second round and address either OL or DL with the top pick. Newton-its a football name.