He gets beats so many times every game it's scary and inconsistent would pretty much mean overrated, no? Just about every team has good receivers, saying that because he covered Tavon Austin well in one example doesn't prove (or disprove) your point. Count how many times he gets beat in a game, and I'm not talking about perfect throws to a receiver who makes a play, and you'll find quite a few instances every game where he's getting torched. Keep in mind, I'm tackling this from an angle where announcers say he's a top CB, and I hear that very often. I point that out just for perspective.