I think it is you that has no clue.
The argument was against Peterman, and was yeah he looked ok but it was against the 3's, then it was the same but it was against the 2's, lets see him do it against the 1's then we'll know.
Well he just did it against the 1's, thrown into the game, probably didn't take any 1st team reps and is a true rookie to boot. What more does the kid have to do? He has shown well in every instance you all challenged him in.