New Top-15 Board

[BillsFanForever19]

About a month ago I posted my Top-15 draft board. Everyone seems to have their own with different players ranked at different places. Here's mine; tell me what you think and post yours:

 

1.) Reggie Bush, RB USC

2.) Vince Young, QB Texas

3.) D'Brickashaw Ferguson, OT Virginia

4.) Matt Leinart, QB USC

5.) Mario Williams, DE N.C. State

6.) A.J. Hawk, LB Ohio State

7.) Vernon Davis, TE Maryland

8.) DeAngelo Williams, RB Memphis

9.) Jay Cutler, QB Vanderbilt

10.) Michael Huff, S/CB Texas

11.) Haloti Ngata, DT Oregon

12.) Lendale White, RB USC

13.) Tamba Hali, DE Penn State

14.) Chad Greenway, OT Iowa

15.) Santonio Holmes, WR Ohio State

[buffaloboyinATL]

I'm not sure Chad Greenway should be in the top 15 anymore and I personally think DeAngelo Williams should slip a few spots.

[Astrobot]

Here's Mine. I'm more about position. Bush is too good not to include, though.

Long About #10 I'd be inclined to trade down.

 

1. D'Brickashaw Ferguson OT

2. Haloti Ngata, DT

3. Reggie Bush, RB

4. Mario Williams DE

5. Vernon Davis TE

6. Winston Justice RT

7. Matt Leinart, QB

8. Tamba Hali DE

9. Michael Huff FS

10. AJ Hawk LB

[JimBob2232]

1.) Reggie Bush, RB USC

2.) Vince Young, QB Texas

3.) D'Brickashaw Ferguson, OT Virginia

4.) Matt Leinart, QB USC

5.) Mario Williams, DE N.C. State

6.) A.J. Hawk, LB Ohio State

7.) Vernon Davis, TE Maryland

8.) DeAngelo Williams, RB Memphis

9.) Jay Cutler, QB Vanderbilt

10.) Michael Huff, S/CB Texas

11.) Haloti Ngata, DT Oregon

12.) Lendale White, RB USC

13.) Tamba Hali, DE Penn State

14.) Chad Greenway, OT Iowa

15.) Santonio Holmes, WR Ohio State

 

Are you making a top 15 overall board, or your top 15 bills board?

 

This is my top 15 BILLS board

 

1) Bush

2) Mario Williams

3) Hawk

4) Leinert

5) Ferguson

6) Vernon Davis

7) Huff

8) Ngata

9) Williams

10)Cutler

11) Hali

12)Young

13) Winston Justice

14) Chad Jackson

15) Chad Greenway

[Tasker]

Are you making a top 15 overall board, or your top 15 bills board?

 

This is my top 15 BILLS board

 

1) Bush

2) Mario Williams

3) Hawk

4) Leinert

5) Ferguson

6) Vernon Davis

7) Huff

8) Ngata

9) Williams

10)Cutler

11) Hali

12)Young

13) Winston Justice

14) Chad Jackson

15) Chad Greenway

617723[/snapback]

 

You would rather have Bush and Willis than Mario and Willis?

[BillsFanForever19]

Are you making a top 15 overall board, or your top 15 bills board?

617723[/snapback]

 

Top 15 based on skill and value. Not by need.

[JimBob2232]

You would rather have Bush and Willis than Mario and Willis?

 

Absolutley. There is so much Reggie Bush can do for your team. He doesnt need to REPLACE Willis, they can co-exist on the field at the same time. He is an invaluable resource on offense.

 

If he falls to #8 (no way in h-e-doulble hockey sticks), I take him in a second. If I had thre #1 overall pick, I take bush in a second, end of story.

[bert]

1Reggie Bush

2Mario Williams

3A.J. Hawk

4D'Brickashaw Ferguson

5Matt Leinart

6Vince Young

7Vernon Davis

8Michael Huff

9DeAngelo Williams

10Haloti Ngata

11Jay Cutler

12Chad Greenway

13LenDale White

14Santonio Holmes

15Laurence Maroney

[JimBob2232]

9DeAngelo Williams

10Haloti Ngata

11Jay Cutler

12Chad Greenway

13LenDale White

14Santonio Holmes

15Laurence Maroney

 

3 RBs from 9 to 15? If we are doing a bills board, this is way too many. While Reggie Bush is unique in that he can compliment willis, and they can both be on the field at the same time, White, D. Williams and Maroney would replace willis. Even if you think thats an upgrade (and it may be), the step up is nowhere near getting a Chad Greenway.

 

Also, while I like holmes alot, he is not the top WR on my board. Chad Jackson is. Holmes is an undersized burner. Much like Lee evans. and although every team can use a player of his calibur, we have one, and dont really need 2. we need a long term replacement to EM, and Chad Jackson could be that guy.