dailar Posted December 28, 2010 Share Posted December 28, 2010 Everyone has an opinion on whether Fitz is good enough, whether Donte is underrated, whether Kyle is pro bowl quality or whether we should trade Lee Evans. I just think its time to rate the Bills to see where are and where we need improvement. There are people who say we are so bad that we should cut the whole roster but that’s rubbish, the fact is we need some impact players to put us over the edge. We have the basis of a good team here now. Anyway I will leave this up to you and perhaps collate the ratings at the end. Here's my take on it for what its worth. 1-2 Not good enough 2-4 Below average 5-6 adequate NFL talent 7-8 Good player 9 Great player 10 Elite player Obviously players such as rookies or with an upside can have two ratings for example Arthur Moats is a perhaps a 7 but could grow to be a 9. This is all subjective obviously but at least it gets you being honest about where we are. Ryan Fitzpatrick - 6 Fred Jackson - 8 CJ Spiller - 6 but could rise to a 9 Corey McIntyre - 7 Lee Evans - 7 David Nelson - 7 but could rise to a 9 Stevie Johnson - 8 Donald Jones - 6 but could rise to a 8 Marcus Easley - only going on reports pre season but he sounds like the real deal, who knows. Roscoe Parrish - in this new offence 7 Naaman Roosevelt - 6 but could be an 8 The O line is not my bag as I am honest enough to say the little intricacies leave me lost but I know you lot sound like you know what you're talking about most of the time Bell - 6 but his star is on the rise, could be an 8 if he can build up his strength Levitre - our best lineman this year who knows how good he can be 7 Wood - 6 but could get to a 9 at centre. terrific upside Geoff Hangartner - 7 The others are very young too and look like they may have a future here in fairness. Howard, Wrotto, Ubrick and Rinehart looked to be decent enough and could improve with playing time. Wang I don’t know yet. However, though pass protection has improved immensely run blocking is woeful. Kyle Williams - 9-10........ enough said Alex Carrington - in the limited time we have seen him 6 but there is talent there, may get to an 8 Kellen Heard NT Spencer Johnson - 6 Marcus Stroud - has sadly dropped to a 6 and is only going to get worse Torell Troup - the same as carrington really 6 but could get to an 8 with time Dwan Edwards - 7 Akin Ayodele - 6 Chris Kelsay - 6 Aaron Maybin - 2 Arthur Moats - 7 but could be a 9 Paul Posluszny - 7 Merriman - if he gets fit he's exceptional. Davis - When hes fit he's a 7 Jairus Byrd - 7 but is getting better all the time, could yet make it to a 9 Reggie Corner - 6 Drayton Florence - 7 Terrence McGee - 7 Leodis McKelvin - 7 Bryan Scott - 6 Donte Whitner - 7 George Wilson - 7 Ashton Youboty - 6 I know there are no TE's mentioned but I don’t think I need to. We haven’t got any! I may have forgotten someone so I am sorry if I have. I will wait for the first numbskull who gives out 1's across the board. Its bound to happen. And be kind. Have just watched the Eddie Guerrero RAW tribute from 2005 and I am very emotional! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
H2o Posted December 28, 2010 Share Posted December 28, 2010 Too much work. I think we are between the 24th-27th best team in the NFL right now. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CodeMonkey Posted December 28, 2010 Share Posted December 28, 2010 Ryan Fitzpatrick - 6 Fred Jackson - 6 CJ Spiller - 5 Corey McIntyre - 5 Lee Evans - 7 David Nelson - 5 Stevie Johnson - 6 Donald Jones - 5 Roscoe Parrish - 7 Naaman Roosevelt - 5 Bell - 5 Levitre - 6 Wood - 5 Geoff Hangartner - 5 Kyle Williams - 7 Marcus Stroud - 6 Torell Troup - 5 Dwan Edwards - 6 Akin Ayodele - 6 Chris Kelsay - DE 6 LB 2 Aaron Maybin - 2 Arthur Moats - 6 Paul Posluszny - 6 Jairus Byrd - 6 Reggie Corner - 6 Drayton Florence - 6 Terrence McGee - 7 Leodis McKelvin - 6 Bryan Scott - 6 Donte Whitner - 7 George Wilson - 7 Ashton Youboty - 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bills99999 Posted December 29, 2010 Share Posted December 29, 2010 Ryan Fitzpatrick - 6 Fred Jackson - 8 CJ Spiller - 4 Corey McIntyre - 3 Lee Evans - 4 David Nelson - 4 Stevie Johnson - 5 Donald Jones - 4 Roscoe Parrish - 5 Naaman Roosevelt - 6 Bell - 5 Levitre - 6 Wood - 6 Geoff Hangartner - 7 Kyle Williams - 8 Alex Carrington - 5 Spencer Johnson - 4 Marcus Stroud - 4 Torell Troup - 4 Dwan Edwards - 5 Akin Ayodele - 4 Chris Kelsay - 4 Aaron Maybin - 0 Arthur Moats - 6 Paul Posluszny - 6 Davis - When hes fit he's a 5 Jairus Byrd - 7 Reggie Corner - 4 Drayton Florence - 4 Terrence McGee - 5 Leodis McKelvin - 5 Bryan Scott - 5 Donte Whitner - 3 George Wilson - 4 Ashton Youboty - 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thoner7 Posted December 29, 2010 Share Posted December 29, 2010 4 the Bills as a whole are below average and just below adequate. KW is a 10 and everyone else is a couple notches closer to 4. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts