Interesting post. I think you still need to take a QB in the first round if he has that kind of talent.
The problem comes when these QBs don't live up to expectations even before they make the playoffs. I, for one, will be glad when I don't have to watch David Carr take another snap in the NFL. The guy is terrible.
If you will remember, the Ravens have had a terrible QB situation, before and after the Cal QB they took in round #1.
They tried Stoney Case, etc. etc.