Yah, your right. He is a complete bust because he couldn't put up monster numbers as a 21 or 22 year old. Give me a break! I'll agree with you about is lack of defensive abilities, but not many younger players have the ability to compete as a defensive powerhouse and/or consistantly win faceoffs. I doubt you would think any different of him if he backchecked a little more, and won a few more faceoffs.
You give a KID two years and determine he is not showing signs of getting better... hmm... If you look at his career totals, his points per year increased his first 3 years in his career. Not to mention, he was the 3rd leading scorer on the team his first year with the team. I guess based on your rationality, he reached his max potential at 21-22 years old since "he isn't showing signs of getting better." ha!
I mean, seriously, what do you expect out of him? He had one horrible season, and he didnt play the next because of an injury.