Kevin1778

The McCarron hairline fractured collarbone didn't help. An injury like that puts a team in a tough spot. Behind this line he likely would have broken it again.

Neither player was handled well by the Bills. Tyrod should have been given those two road games at San Diego and KC and then the Pats game. If he just kept being Tyrod he should have been replaced in a softer spot like at home against the Colts. Who gives a rookie his first start in a game on the road against the #3 defense in the NFL. Insane.

I changed it to Not a Big Fan.

I know. Just curious if it is 50-50 supporters and haters or something like 80-20 one way or the other. It is hard to tell if he is really hated or if it is just a few loud people and the national media. I don't think the Bills fans are as down on him as people say.

Curious where he stands on this board. Made a little revision to the choices after listening to replies.

Maybe he lights it up with the Bills and gets a big deal off it. Anyone who can put up big numbers with this offense will have to be pretty good. He did have 1000 yds just in 2016. He makes plays.

You may be right. Why on earth would you risk your health for a 2-6 team with no offensive line. The Bills should put him on IR and pay him and let him go out with what was an ok Monday Night effort. He likely thought he would mentor and hold a clipboard and maybe come in and play a down or two. No way he signed up for two brutal beatings.

I saw articles and tweets saying Josh Gordon would be benched for 1st quarter against Bill's too. Fake. Idiots just make up these fake stories for likes and clicks.

Again, he didn't play against the Colts. Are you talking about the Texans where he threw a TD and 2 picks after he came in and played behind a line that got Allen knocked out after he threw zero touchdowns? And I am not angry, I just am annoyed Bill's fans listen to these idiot national reporters that act like the Bill's line and receivers are not an issue and it is all Peterman. They lost the last two games and our QB turned the ball over SIX times with a pick 6 and had no touchdowns. His name wasn't Peterman.

First, he didn't play against the Colts. It was Derek Anderson who had 4 turnovers and no touchdowns in a 37-5 loss. Second, when Peterman did start against the Colts in 2017, the Bills won and he was 5 of 10 for 57 yards with a TD and no interceptions. Yes, the Bills have won when Peterman started. In fact they are 1-0 at home when he starts.

Agreed. Peterman should have been QB against Colts and Patriots. Anderson wasn't in shape and didn't know the playbook. What did McDermott get by playing Anderson? An injured quarterback who has 6 turnovers and no touchdowns against two of the worst defenses in the NFL. They were outscored 62-11. And guess what, Peterman is starting again.

He is a good receiver. His off season antics hurt his reputation a little, and the inability of the offensive line to block has led to some problems for quarterbacks getting the ball to receivers. He actually has good chemistry with Peterman. Expect a TD from his this Sunday.

Don't be surprised if there is a large Jimmy Kimmel sucks sign at New Era Field this week. ?

No. The crowd is 100% with him when he gets in there. He hasn't played a bad game at home. Not a single pick.

He isn't the worst in history. You listen to too many idiots in the national media. Guys like Randy Fasani have worse career ratings. The media just lies. I posted his home game stats in the first post in this thread. They are fine. Stop believing idiots and their made up narratives.

You have no idea what you are talking about. Peterman played just TWO awful games. Both on the road. One as a rookie against the #3 defense in the NFL and one as a second year QB against the #1 defense in the NFL. He was fine against the Texans. He gave the Defense a lead. The fact he put up the only Bill's passing TD in last 23 quarters and he did it trailing by a few points in a close game shows he can play.

He struggles on the road against VERY good defenses. He has looked good at home. Stop listening to the idiots. Peterman is not that bad.

He may be the shot of confidence the Bill's offense needs. Good signing because he has to prove himself. He has the talent if healthy.

He plays well at home. Maybe he gets a win here and gets some confidence and takes it on the road for the Jets. He started against the #1 and #3 defenses in the NFL on the road. Even great quarterbacks would struggle in those spots.

He belongs. He has been asked to start two road games against the #1 and #3 defenses in the NFL. Not easy for a veteran, let alone a rookie or 2nd year QB. It is a question of whether he is a future backup or the third guy on roster. He isn't going anywhere. He gets paid virtually nothing which frees up money for others on roster.

No he isn't. PR nightmares are when human being are hurt badly. This is a sport. Not life. Peterman doesn't lose games any worse than the guy he is replacing anyway.

Want? How about supporting the ONLY healthy quarterback we have. He is QB3. QB1 and QB2 are hurt. There is nobody else.

Peterman is starting. They aren't putting a 35 year old guy coming off a concussion on the field. It is a PR nightmare if he gets hurt, not to mention insane. This bad line could literally get him killed. Anderson will be out through the bye. You don't play games with a guys health when he did you a favor coming out of retirement to mentor your QB.

They also beat the Titans and Vikings. You never know which team will show up.

Not sure about that but his struggles might have something to do with his two road starts being against the #1 and #3 defenses in the NFL.